Minister will reconstitute national lotto department if Maltco wins injunction
Government will run lotteries itself if Maltco wins injunction against call for tenders, finance minister tells court.
Finance Minister Tonio Fenech has warned that the government will be forced to reconstitute the lotto department once again, if it is not allowed to go ahead with a new call for tenders for the private operation of the national lottery.
He was testifying in the court of Joseph Zammit McKeon, which is hearing submissions from lotto operator Maltco for an injunction on the call for tenders for the operation of the national lotteries.
Maltco was granted a seven-year tenure for the operation of the national lotteries which was extended for a year, up to July 2012. But the government informed the company in March it will be issuing a new call for tenders in 2012.
The court will now decide in the coming days whether the preliminary injunction currently in force is to stay.
The attorneys of Gtech - the local representative of Italian lotteries operator Lottomatica - asked the court to be part of the procedures as a prospective bidder in the call for tenders, claiming they would be prejudiced in their interest to do business in Malta and participate in the call for tenders.
But Judge Zammit McKeon threw out their request, despite the Attorney General's own submission that European jurisprudence backed the participation of third parties in such cases; stating that Maltese law had not yet been updated to transpose the cited jurisprudence.
Finance Minister Tonio Fenech said it was a Cabinet decision to issue a call for tenders for the renewal of the national lottery licence, following the expiry of the Maltco licence. According to the licence conditions, the government could extend the licence for either seven years or just one.
Fenech said the lotteries' concession was considered to be of high national importance given the economic situation, which is why a call for tender had to be issued.
Fenech was then asked by the Court what damages government would suffer if the call for tenders had to be halted, and the minister said it would have no other option but to re-establish the lotto department and organise the games itself.
Fenech said this would cost the country substantial financial income, and that Maltco had every right to participate in a clear and transparent call for tender.
Maltco's legal counsel Prof. Ian Refalo however argued that government had acted beyond its remit in taking a decision not to consult Maltco over the renewal of the seven-year damage.
Refalo argued that Maltco would suffer 'patrimonial damages' since the way things had been done, it looked like Maltco would be put out of business and obliged to hand over its business to some else.
Refalo said that government had to consider a seven-year renewal on the basis of Maltco's good performance.
Attorney General Peter Grech and the Lotteries and Gaming Authority's legal counsel Joseph Vella however stressed that Maltco's contract stipulated that the licence condition was valid for seven years.
Additionally, Maltco's accounts had provided for the payment of a €17 million concession fee to the government, spread over a period of eight years: the seven-year licence and a one-year extension.