Is Israel a rogue state?

The attack on a flotilla carrying aid to Gaza is another sign of the degeneration of an Israeli nationalism corrupted by an occupation which dehumanizes colonised and colonisers alike.

I have to admit that I have great admiration for the Jewish people for surviving as an ethnic community despite all the attempts to eradicate them.

And while I doubt whether Israel can prosper as an exclusively Jewish entity divorced from its Arab Middle Eastern surroundings, historically the setting up of a homeland for the Jews did give this persecuted ethnic group a sense of purpose which comes through nation building.

Israel is here to stay. My hope is that it will be able to re-invent itself as a Jewish-Arab liberal democratic hub existing side by side along emerging secular Arab democracies in Lebanon and Palestine, freed from Iranian and Syrian hegemony.

But nothing can be further away from this utopian vision than the present. Israeli patriotism has been deformed by the brute occupation of another people. The sense of historical victimhood seems to have endowed Israel with the right to behave as if it was above international law. Israel has assumed the right to use military force against anyone standing in its path. Anyone standing in its way is labeled a terrorist and a fair target.

This attitude makes Israel a rogue state whose only way to survive is by creating mayhem, which foments the clash of fundamentalisms which destabilizes the Middle East.

The Israeli right-wing seems to share a common interest with Iran; destabilisation and mayhem. The corruption of Israel's soul was more than confirmed by recent revelations on its dealings with apartheid South Africa. The very idea of the children of the Shoah offering the atom bomb to a country run by neo-Nazi sympathizers makes me puke.

Only America (and perhaps the international Jewish lobby) can save Israel from becoming its worst enemy by pulling the plug. Those who love Israel have to stand up to be counted.

The military attack on a peace flotilla is a clear warning that time is running out to save Israel from its alter ego.

avatar
I do not even know where to begin to comment. Do you really believe it's that simple or that black and white? I find this piece an extremely superficial analysis of a very complex reality. The Israel = bad thesis is full of very big holes. Many moderate Israelis (which is not exactly identical to Jews) and moderate Palestinians will conceed that BOTH sides are partly responsible for the present impasse. The share of the blame will of course differ according to who you are speaking to. Israel is not responsible for the fact that Palestinian factions were at each other's throat in Gaza nor is it responsible for the corruption and lack of real commitment to state building. To mention just a couple of things. The list is indeed much longer.
avatar
Raymond DeBattista
What a load of superficial hogwash. Israel under siege and in a state of perpetual war with most of it's neighbours hell bent to destroy it has created one hell of a democracy, which even we in Malta only dream we can ever reach. 20% of it's population are Arabs who notwithstanding everything would never dream of living in an other Arab state.Israel absorbed nearly a million Jews expelled from Arab countries, but no Arab country has absorbed the Arabs who now call themselves Palestinians. Israel doesn't have to re-invent herself - it is a vibrant, ultra-modern democracy, with an economy going stronger and stronger. Is it ok to have a Catholic Malta, and a Muslim Arab country (22 of them in fact) but not a Jewish state? Come-over mate ! Grow up.
avatar
Lino Bonett
"The very idea of the children of the Shoah offering the atom bomb to a country run by neo-Nazi sympathizers makes me puke." Indeed.
avatar
Norman Buckle
This opinion piece begs the question: How many of Mr. Debono's best friends are Jews? Boy, you do need to study your Maltese History, from which you would learn that, if a Churchill were the Prime Minister of Israel, this is how he would end the conflict: Carpet-bomb Gaza; nuke Tehran and Damascus. Then there will be peace for at least 65 years.