Is this the Europe I voted for? Not quite

I am increasingly disenchanted by this Europe which seems to care a lot about markets and very little on human rights.

Unlike many Nationalists who were and still are little islanders at heart, I wanted Malta to join the EU not because of the "mitt miljun" (€100 million) but because I wanted my country to join a political union based on the firm respect for human rights, secular values, civil liberties, environmental protection and social rights.

My belief in the EU fairytale has been seriously undermined by the new Director-General for Migration, Stefano Manservisi, who declared that agreement between Italy and Libya through which migrants rescued on the high seas by Italy (and Malta?) are taken back by Libya is "perfectly in conformity with EU law.” It might conform with EU law but not with the spirit of the European project based on the vision of Europe as a beacon of human rights.

Not that this was ever the case. For national European governments have a history of collaboration with murderous third world regimes. But at least the Union is expected to show some moral high ground. In this case in a perfectly neo-colonialist way, Italy is farming out the expulsion of migrants to Libya, a pariah state which is not bound by the Geneva convention. It is an approach similar to that adopted by some western states in the war on terror; namely that of leaving despotic regimes to do the butchering.

Now we are told that Italy has the EU blessing. No wonder responsibility sharing seems to have evaporated from the agenda. That says a lot about the priorities of the right-wing Barroso commission. So instead of coming up with a reasonable system of responsibility sharing of asylum seekers in which everyone plays his part, Barroso's Europe is simply allowing Italy (and Malta?) to farm out their problems to a pariah state. And government and PN representatives are playing its part by ass-licking Libya all the time...

At least in Mintoff's days when the Nationalists used to express revulsion at Malta's close ties with Libya, we gained some bargaining power to snatch money from Italy and the UK by pampering Ghaddafi's ego. But what the hell are we getting now, except BP drilling on our doorstep?

vanrompuyashton

But my disenchantment with Europe goes beyond the migration issue. The European Union has become the most uncharismatic institution in the world. Who the hell are Von Rompuy and Lady Ashton (pictured)? It is a pity that the EU is not led by someone of the stature of former German foreign Minister Joshcka Fiscer. By putting the spokes on Turkey's membership bid, the EU is becoming more and more an exclusive club with no ambition to reach out. The catastrophic result of this policy is Turkey drifting eastwards towards Iran.

An EU which stands for nothing except economic liberalisation has no soul. Surely many of these liberalisations pushed by the EU are perfectly justified and commendable for making the consumer king. But not enough emphasis is put on strengthening the social model which makes Europe a better place to live than the USA.

In the absence of new revenue flows, the blind obsession with deficit-cutting could erode this model. Not surprisingly the neo-liberals, the meek social democrats and the anachronistic far-left are all paving the way for the national chauvinists who would like the Union scrapped.

The EU was once a fact of life. Today its future is very uncertain. And that is not a good thing.

avatar
Dear James, I never was a CNI convert. How did you come to that? It was you who wrote that you believed in "the EU fairytale". And mind you, the question was not whether to join EU or not and that's it but whether or not to join EU on a particular date. I voted NO in the referendum because I too believe in your EU but unlike you, I could see back then that it was a fairytale and more important, we were not ready yet for that quantum leap. As for going back in time,yes, you would still go back to that same point in time to vote YES for your fairytale because nothing will change. In a multiverse even if you would do the same tje outcome will be different.
avatar
Alfred Galea
Do you want the EU to welcome thousands and thousands of ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS ferried over by HUMAN TRAFFICKERS to settle in Europe, putting a strain on the Union's social safety net?? Do you want the EU to admit Turkey, with its seventy millions muslims? Because it'll drift towards Iran otherwise?? Sort of like having an "enemy within"?? Don't tell me that you didn't know that for the 855,000,000 euros Malta was gonna become a colony again? The Ellis Island of Europe? Don't tell me that you didn't know that Malta would have absolutely no say in certain things that affect it and how? Don't tell me you didn't know that the EU was gonna shove a constitution down your throat whether you agree with it or not?? Jimmy, you and others like you made your bed, now you lie in it. The circle is complete, the PN won independence from Britain and the PN sold Malta to the EU......... I can only dream of what would have been had some politician with the negotiating skill of Dom Mintoff carried the torch instead of those ass-licking, ass-kissing wimps who became rich off the backs of the Maltese.
avatar
Charles Caruana
There is nothing wrong with the EU; what is wrong is the way the EU was marketed in Malta, as some sort of fat, mature cow having its nipples swollen with eagerness to spray millions of Euros and other mannas to the Maltese! And....the Maltese loved it and fell for it...including our James. However, what made the situation verging on the ridiculous, were the negotiations, which were a one way ticket for the EU to ride on! To get an idea how the PN ( Fenech Adami and Gonzi) witness the recent negotiations with the bus drivers.....bus drivers were given a multi million deal to promote change etc..and yet.......they will be again the preferrred bidders! Can you imagine these bombastic high profile Nationalist negotiators and ministers dealing with the EU if they can.t even deal with local" sophisticated" bus drivers? And again we are being invaded by illegal immigrants because the PN signed all the papers which others ( with hind sight) would have refused to sign! Believe in burden sharing and you get burden dumping...thats what professional politics is all about.So please James, you were part of the problem and therefore blame yourself and others who believed in the PN's bluff!
avatar
It appears that one of the conditions to work at M T is that you have to be an illegal immigrant lover. Appart from that, M T has the most juicy scoops.
avatar
Peter Cassar

Dear il-googol just because am critical of the Barroso commission does not make me a late CNI convert.  My current criticism is based on the same values which made me vote yes in 2003.   I would still vote yes if i had to go back in time and i would still disagree with the little islander mentality of the no movement which is also shared by many nationalists

avatar
dear james, the problem is that you never wanted to listen. i can still remember your smiles of disbelief when people like "le" side made their arguments . all YOU were interested in was to ridicule dr alfred sant, tony zarb and others. seems that your pro eu stand was based on fables.
avatar
The European Union are getting into deep financial trouble and handing billions of euros to countries like Greece who can't balance their books, so they turn to others to bail them out will not go down well with the rest of the EU countries. How is this any different from your neighbor (who spends all his money on fancy cars and gadgets) showing up at your door, threatening to sabotage the neighborhood unless you help him with his mortgage payments. Why should Malta, together with the rest of the EU countries pay for someone else's stupidity.
avatar
very good article james but please it is lady ashton!:)
avatar
I think that Dr Alfred Sant was speeking the truth about European Union from what is happening most of that who voted YES for UE now they are SORRY .The first think that in my opinion the UE is ridicouasly doing is a SIMPLE thing the FLAG it still bears only 16 stars why did they not change the flag and do it with 26 stars the number that are in UE because the new members they don't bother about them (2) the Euro the coin that most of the countries use its going DOWN and without value compared with the Sterling and the Dollar and the other coins (3) after Greeks DISASTER There is going to be trouble in Spain and Portugall we (Maltese) are with the same problems like these 2 countries and Ireland is facing a disaster like Spain and Portugall 2 so what are we benifiting from UE apart from the FINES that e are going to GET because we are BACK in most of the rules that UE impose today we heard that UE accusedr Dr GONZIPN that he BROKE the rules about HUNTING