Killing in the name of

Political parties can only come clean on the fireworks issue if they cut their links with the fireworks lobby.

From time to time the United States is shocked by killing sprees committed by some teenager who manages to get hold of a gun, something facilitated by the constitutional right to bear arms.

But despite the shock and anguish the gun lobby manages to thwart any attempt to regulate the availability of guns. This is because the gun lobby has the support of many in the redneck Republican Party and quite a few in the supposedly liberal Democratic Party.

From time to time Malta is also shocked by fireworks tragedies. Every time a factory explodes we hear of new regulations and inquires. But despite the shock and anguish nothing changes until the next factory explodes. Similarly to the gun lobby in the US, the local fireworks lobby has the support of a number of MPs who thwart any call for regulation.

The resistance to calls for a moratorium on firework production until an inquiry on the latest tragedy is finalised, is yet another sign of the power of the fireworks lobby. What is even more shocking is that the supposedly progressive Labour Party is opposing such a moratorium.

Probably my friends in the Labour Party will tell me “what does this has to do with being progressive?” It’s the same reaction I get when I ask them about their jingoistic support for tuna farming and their pandering for hunters’ votes. In reality as long as Labour panders for the redneck vote, it will never become palatable for cosmopolitan voters who resent this conservative streak.

The reality is that Labour includes within its parliamentary ranks fireworks enthusiasts whose world view is as parochial as that of any conservative rural Nationalist. Surely one can say the same thing about the Nationalist Party posing as the party of Europeanisation.

What is striking is that there is not even a trace of dissent in the parliamentary groups of both parties on this issue. The only person to challenge the fireworks lobby in the PN was Georg Sapiano, who in his soul searching after the MEP elections debacle had identified his party’s weakness in tackling this issue as a reason for its declining electoral fortunes. I guess it is one of those defining issues which would decide the fate of the PN as popular liberal party or a national conservative party.

It seems that even modernizers in both parties fear losing votes if they dare challenge the fireworks lobby. AD has scored points by challenging both parties on this issue. For on this issue it is clear that in both parties, the traditionalists rule the roost.

What Malta needs now is alliance of modernizers capable of rocking the boat and confronting redneck Malta in a tit-for-tat struggle for modernization. As far as I am concerned the struggle for modernity and making Malta a normal country takes priority over any other issue.

avatar
@gogole and RC The 80s government might not have been great but did not have a PM (EFA) who was found 5 times, at least, guilty by the court for breaking human rights. The latest being the suspension of 3 policeman nine years back. Don't forget either that this same person was found guilty of lieing against his opponent and fined Lm2000. Right the 80s goverment wasn't great.
avatar
Alfred Galea
Jimmy, the right to bear arms in the US is protected by the second amendment of the US constitution, and it was recently upheld by the SCOTUS. Has nothing to do with Republicans or rednecks. And I hope you would agree with me that gun control doesn't stop criminals obtaining and using guns to commit crimes. It's just a pain in the ass for LEGAL gun owners.
avatar
Where did i say 80's labour gov was great? another sweet tooth fanatic? sorry jamie but thought you were older- in fact you do look older- i apologise for the mistook assumption.
avatar
The real problem is that we have a Health and Safety unit which is doing nothing to solve the problem. This entity is like many of its kind, that is, was thought up as a way to employ the blue eyed boys. You only hear of it when they happen to inspect some retaurant or small fry hotel and find some unhealty and unsafe situations. How many constructionsites have a warning that entering such site requires PPE, like a hard hat, and how many of those that sometimes have such a billboard yoiu find workers not wearing the minimum PPE, not even hard hats. Hard hats are reserved for gonzi and his cronies when they visit a site and the cameras are rolling. The same is with the fireworks problem, there is no clear guide lines, no proper laws and no proper surveillance by the HEALTH and SAFETY dept., which means gonziPN is to blame.
avatar
Georgette Bezzina
@ James Debono definition of Gladio: The P.N. objection to a moratoriom was publicly explained to-day by Minister Mifsud Bonnici;yet you still havn't REVEALED IT YET! Gladio (Italian for Gladius, a type of Roman short sword) is a code name denoting the clandestine NATO "stay-behind" operation in Italy after World War II, intended to continue anti-communist actions in the event of a Warsaw Pact invasion of Western Europe. (Wikipidia). @markanthony Yes I would definitely do the same; If I happen to have lived there before the Fireworks factory was built. This same problem cropped with people who bought land at Qajenza near to the present Gas Installation. They knew that they were building next to a time bomb, yet they forged ahead.
avatar
Peter Cassar
I was only 12 years old in 1987
avatar
Gilbert Bartolo
oh wow! googol...another blinkered partisan telling us that 80s Labour was great! some people are really incredibly .....
avatar
Gilbert Bartolo
it is incredible that when a product is faulty there is a product recall, but some cannot stomach a moratorium i.e. a temporary halt to manufacture, until the mechanisms behind the repeated explosions are crystal clear.... this is called fanaticism and sheer pigheadedness... in other countries it would be the commonsense thing to do...but no not in provincial backwater malta.... murtali akkost ta' kollox mhux accettabbli...
avatar
It is good to hear that our friend James debono agrees at least with the socialist government way back in the 80's regarding the fireworks moratorium. pity that he did his utmost to bring down that government and rescinding that moratorium. By his argument then, these deaths should be on his conscience too and he is partly responible.
avatar
David Bongailas
With all due respect Mr.Debono but your argument is just too weak and simplistic. You just seem to equate fireworks with rednecks ergo with conservatism. But aren't we all conservative on some topics and liberal on others ? So just wanting a ban of fireworks makes you a liberal these days ? Since when ?! I hold a post-graduate degree, I favour divorce and gay marriage and in some cases abortion too but yes fireworks are an important part of my life. So by your definition one aspect of my life makes me a conservative redneck ?! Don't think so! And by the by I have always voted AD in general elections.
avatar
Peter Cassar
@censinu- Fireworks are a big threat to farmers working land next to these time bombs. I have consistently documented attempts to build factories in agricultural areas. I even wrote about the dubious permit issued for the factory which exploded, the proposed Gharb fireworks factory and the protests of farmers which led MEPA to refuse fireworks factories in Rabat. I admit that my reference to rural mentalities is a bit stereotypical. What i meant was parochialism which in malta can be rural and urban. Secondly my criticism was also directed at the PN. Is labour a sacred cow? @gladio- Your choice of name is quite revealing. Gladio??? was that not some ill conceived attempt to block italian democracy which ended up in the hands of stragisti and P2? Quite a name to defend the progressive agenda!
avatar
Why do the Maltese need any political party to make them understand that fireworks are dangerous whether they are used in religious feasts or international competition. How many more people must die and how many more children must be orphaned and how many more private properties must be destroyed before this country grows up and discard this medieval practice. It's the people that donate the monies to manufacture these dangerous fireworks that are the cause for all these deaths. The Curia told us that voting for divorce is a sin but the death of 6 people for the sake of setting up fireworks for a religious feast is just an aberration in human tragedy. How utterly sick can this nation continue in this matter. And for all those delittanti that claim that they cannot live without fireworks, please make sure you buy huge insurance coverage when you apply for your licence, to ensure that your wife or children are looked after and your neighbour can recover the costs of the damage to his private property when you are blown up to smiterines.
avatar
Jean-Claude Pace
Why do you have such high expectations of Labour? So the Nationalists can protect the tuna farming industry, but Labour can't? Oh well, protests were organised against Labour reforming the stipends system, but nothing was said when the Nationalists did not restore them to the same amounts as promised and when they were reduced. Same thinking..... In what way are fireworks directly related to redneck culture? The usual bashing of anything Maltese? So to modernize Malta, according to you, we should do away with any hint of rural culture left in Malta (not that there is much left anyway)? In what way is progressivism directly associated with urban areas? I wouldn't call Sliema rural, but I don't see much progressivism there...
avatar
John Camilleri
Dear Gladio: damn right Sapiano has a personal interest if, as you say, he lives next door to a fireworks factory. Wouldn't you? At least he tried to do something about it, unlike most politicians from either party. I sincerely doubt that Muscat will make the effort as apparently he has a personal interest too.
avatar
Gilbert Bartolo
Oh my he didn't mention PN too... tribal reasoning... PL=PN= backward tribal politics in a backward provincial so-called 'country'
avatar
Gilbert Bartolo
Oh my he didn't mention PN too... tribal reasoning... PL=PL= backward tribal politics in a backward provincial so-called 'country'
avatar
Georgette Bezzina
Quote "What is even more shocking is that the supposedly progressive Labour Party is opposing such a moratorium" In your haste to criticize the Labour party you forgot to mention that the Nationalist Party was also against the idea. As for Georg Sapiano challenging the Fireworks lobby; everyone knows that he has a personal interest as he lives next to a fireworks factory!