How about introducing a caste system

The picture of a Maltese who cannot speak Maltese alighting on an Arriva bus and being asked to pay the extra tariff for tourists is something that persists in my mind.

I cannot understand how we can tolerate such a thing.

I remember being occasionally mistaken for a Brit while boarding the bus when I was younger, and being asked to pay more. 

But that was daylight robbery.

What is happening on the Arriva buses today is sanctioned robbery.

Is one supposed to present an ID card to prove their nationality?

Or is one expected to say something that confirms one’s nationality?

Perhaps, an ‘ostra’ or an expletive or some form of blasphemy will prove their true Maltese origin.

How is this is supposed to work when you buy a bus ticket from a ticketing machine?  The ticketing machine cannot decipher your nationality. What do you do, sing to the machine: dghajsa sejra ohra gejja!

I’m genuinely sorry… but honestly, someone should have informed Austin Gatt that becoming members of the European Union did not translate into membership a la carte. It meant being citizens of Europe.

Typically, we conveniently forget that when we travel to Europe we enjoy many of the rights of fellow Europeans.

This fact was one of the highlights of the ‘Iva ghall-Ewropa’ campaign. 

Absurd campaigners such as Simon Busuttil even went so far as to equate membership with the importance of passing through passport control and walking past – as if this were the justification for becoming fully fledged EU members.

If you happen to get hurt or sick in Europe, you enjoy health and medical treatment, as the Germans and French would.

In Malta, you still have some clinics who go on treating foreign tourists as special cases, and there are special tariffs for foreigners.

But back to Austin Gatt.

He is not my pet hate. But he has this remarkable ability of shooting himself in the foot.

He has not only screwed up public transport and made the whole project unattractive but he has allowed his henchmen – I am referring to potential PN candidate Manwel Delia – to bless the new tariff policies which are untenable in an EU framework. 

In his haste to differentiate between a resident and a non-resident, he introduced a tariff structure which benefits one over the other.

He cannot do this – at least, not in the way he has devised it.

It was of course seriously compromised by the very fact that the drivers are being asked to screen the nationality based on whether the commuter looks like a Maltese or not.

And Austin, along with his cousin Lou – the one who did not pass the boo test at the Santana concert – are highly unlikely to pass this particular test. 

With a little bit of imagination, you would think that Austin and his cousin – the one he does not talk to – hail from Andrha Pradesh.

I am sure they do not talk Telugu like the citizens of Pradesh but they definitely have their physical features and build.

But as we all know they aren’t Indians, but Gozitans, and were it not for the fact that their faces are recognisable, they could easily be confused with those people from down there.

If my statement is politically incorrect, then so be it.

For if it is the statement which irks readers of this column, I suggest they start worrying about the fact that this country is an embarrassment, when it comes to treating foreigners or Europeans as equals.

And that just talking about the way we treat white foreigners… as soon as they appear slightly dark skinned, we become intrinsically nastier.

And ‘nastier’ is understatement.

Our hang-ups about anything black manifest themselves in our silly commentaries and our mannerisms.

But treating foreigners with a different yardstick is also applied by all those institutions which operate here. The banks, the utility and telephone companies… practically everyone has a different benchmark.

It is perfectly alright if you are rich and loaded. If you are affluent you are welcome… you are even tolerated to such an extent that you can avail yourself of an advantageous tax rate. 

This is not only an unfair society, it is a classist society too. It is one that promotes the idea that, for example, the right type of education is not equal for all. 

And yes, it is this government again that has got it all wrong.

In an apparent effort to scuttle public education, the government continues to subsidise Catholic schools (leaving out private schools by the way), making Catholic schools not only more attractive in their set-up but better organised and prepared than State schools.

On the continent, public schools cater for everyone. In France, Italy and Germany, public schools remain a melting pot of all classes.

The sons and daughters of the carpenter and the banker meet in the same classroom.  Here, they simply do not.

In Malta, the first decision to impose class starts off at kindergarten.

And it continues throughout the other stages in ones’ life.

This approach to life, which is based on ‘us and them’ and is eulogized by the political leaders who, in sum total, practise what they never preach.

They talk of good public schools but still send their kids to private or Catholic schools. They talk of good health care, but still prefer private hospitals.

They praise the public transport system, and promise to use it.

But they all choose to drive with their private cars to work. And all of them – without exception – send their children to private schools.

This is a society which is constructed on the principle of an order based on a ‘caste’ system. Yes, a caste system.

So it’s no wonder that our Transport Minister could easily be a member of Thigala caste.

And if he doesn’t know what that is, he should dress as he usually dresses, and take the first bus that happens to come his way.

avatar
BTW Saviour - spot on once again.
avatar
Sanctioned Robbery described this country to perfection.
avatar
Salv during the times that there was no sense of decency do you remember KMB being ridiculed for coining the slogan. JEW B'XEJN JEW XEJN? In you article you just illustrated the outcome of all that ridicule. Why did it take you so long to figure out that we do have a caste system and it goes back a very long time. Remember a certain Alfred Sant the most scorned PM in our history. Scorned not because he was corrupt but because he want to change our political culture and base it on meritocracy and fairness. He also was aware of the caste when refering to those who have and does who have not. But like KMB Alfred Sant was blowing in the wind. Therefore I find it quite pathetic that you a top journlist of your pedgree should refer to the cast at this last hour
avatar
Sorry Salv "lanca gejja w ohra sejjra" How about Clawdu intoduce finger prints by the machine? xejn xejn nghamlu xi pjacir lill xi hadd tal qalba li ghadu ma kwista xejn!
avatar
Luke Camilleri
Bl-istess ragunament ta konfuxu- Ghalhiex hemm rohs fuq min ghandhu propjeta Ghawdex ( Maltin illi ghandhom residentza wkoll Malta) u Ghawdxin fuq il-Maltin? . Mhux kollha Maltin/ Mhux kollha cittadini tal-Unjoni Ewropeja????? . Ghalhiex ma ghandhom il-Maltin ta' Malta jkollhom l'istess drittijiet bhal maltin ta' Ghawdex u l-Ghawdxin????
avatar
Prosit Salv...jigri l-istess bil-karta anzjan bl-anzjani barranin li huma l-maggoranza tat-turisti fil-granet tax-xitwa li jridu jhallsu u l-Maltin ma jhallsux bhal per ezempju t-tragitt bejn Malta u Ghawdex.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
Brand Malta - www.onlyinmalta/pajjiz-tal-MickeyMouse.com LOL
avatar
Prosit Salv, Sa fl-ahhar xi hadd li jsejjah abjad abjad u iswed iswed, hekk kif inhu, minghajr trijonfalismi u daqq tat-trombi. Ghadna ma xbajniex nisimghu ftahir ta' dawn in-nies falluti fil-karrieri taghhom imma imbaghad insibuhom jmexxu pajjiz a bazi tal-ideologiji politici taghhom. Sakemm titfa l-vot jwieghduk is-sema fl-art, imma mbaghad grazzi hafna u ghall-erwieh. Ifthu ghajnejkom u uzaw dak li hemm bejn widnejkom.
avatar
Abdullah alhrbi
Spot on you summed up Gattism to a T. Like joining Europe was all about doing away with passports! I seriously doubt the ability of those MPs at the forefront of the campaign for Europe to comprehend Europeaness given their behaviour on a number of issues. Is there a European name and shame list for anti European legislation in member states? Austin Gatt is certainly scoring highly on the anti European index. Re state schooling Here at last we have someone who has no difficulty articulating the true situation state education finds itself in and how it is losing out to the Church school system. Why does the state insist on abdicating its responsibilities to the Church ? This only ensures that parents have a non choice in Education i.e. Church school Education. What it also suggests is that it will become much more difficult for state school students to achieve social mobility given that there will be increasingly less investment in state schools. The dream team at the Education Ministry and Division just can't resist working the Old School network can they ? Church school pedigree counts a lot there for all the wrong reasons, they assume their first obligation is towards the Church school system.
avatar
It's not ones nationality that entitles the discounted fares, it's ones residency status. There are many expatriate Maltese who complain for not being granted discounted rates, but we who live and pay our fair share of the tax burden and the recipients of the discounts. And to permit drivers to grant these discounts based on their whim/perceptions is asking for all kinds of shenanigans. It may not be the best system, but on balance it's better than what we had before.
avatar
Desiree' Attard
Last Thursday, I decided to use Arriva to enter Valletta so I boarded the 81 bus from Zejtun. When we got to Tarxien, a wizened old lady boarded the bus, but when asked for her karta anzjan, she told the driver (Maltese driver) that she forgot the damned thing at home, so she offered him her ID card. The driver told her that since she didn't have her karta anzjan on her, she'd have to pay the full fare! The point of all this is that 1. the driver should have his eyes tested. 2. His treatment of the lady surely is not customer service. I'm sure that if this little incident happened before Arriva arrived (no pun intended) on the scene, the little lady would have been charged 23 cents and that would have been the end of the story. So please, DO get your act together.
avatar
Ser nistaqsi MISTOQSIJA LIL KUMMISSARJU TAL PULIZIJA is Sur John Rizzo Sur kummissarju xinhi TISTENNA IL PULIZIJA biex jiehdu PASSI kontra l-ARRIVA Sur John Rizzo TAF KEMM QEDIN JGHABBU NIES BIL WIEQFA TAL ARRIVA TAF LI GILI KIEN HEMM MAL 50 RUH BIL WIEQFA u MIN IKUN IRID JINSEL LANQAS IKUN JISTA XINHI TISTENNA IL PULIZIJA BIEX TIEHU PASSU HALLI JIEQAF DAN L_ABBUZ LI TIGRI XI DIZGRAZZJA ALLA INNIXXIFLI IL SIENI Mal 50 RUH ikun hemm bil WIEQFA Sur KUMMISSARJU ghalhekk NISPERAW li dan l-ABBUZ JIEQAF QABEL TIGRI XI DISGRAZZJA
avatar
Dak li qed tghid int Sur Saviour Balzan huwa kollu minnu ghax irid ikollok WICCEK TA XKUPA biex tigi tghid dak id diskors li qal Dr Austin Gatt ghat Turisti jew IHALLSU dak in NOLL jew ma JIGUX l-Hawn u jekk ma jigux l-hawn jghamlulna pjacir ibqa cert Dr Austin Gatt li jekk ikollok TITLA il karozza tal linja ix xufier JAHSBEK XI PAKISTANI ghax mir RAZZA TAGHHOM GEJ Ghalhekk nitlob lic CWIEC MALTIN bhal ma qallhom il KESHLU l-iehor Dr BEATU Tonio Fenech BIEX LIL PN INTAJRUH min hemm minthomx taraw ja qabda CWIEC li INTHOM (POPLU) iz ZEJT rega NISEL fil PREZZ tieghu u il gvern ta Dr Lawrence Gonzi IRID JERGA JGHOLLILNA IL KONTIJIET TA DAWL U L-ILMA ghalhekk TIBQAWX CWIEC U ivvotaw lil PL halli NEHILSU min dan il MISHUT ta Gvern li hafna mil ministri li ghandu qed JAHSBU li LAHQU is SEMA ghax qed jaraw lil KULLHADD DUBBIEN
avatar
How refreshingly true. Mr. Balzan, this has got to be one of your better blogs. prosit
avatar
I agree 100% with this article. I swear that I was explaining the maltese system on these issues to an italian friend about a year ago and he could not really believe this class issue as he was saying that they all go to the same schools etc except for some very high profile vips because of security issues. Now I will forward him this article as you explained it a little better than I did.Well done. One last thought --Who do these people think they are?---imagine if they had nordic features lol