Why Carmelo, and not the others?

Franco Debono’s relentless criticism of Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici may be justified on some levels, but shouldn’t other ministers also be criticised?

Home Affairs minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici.
Home Affairs minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici.

This morning I was having an espresso at Cordina. I was approached by an irate Franco Debono, and in the presence of others, he said that he was pleased to hear that Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici would step down as Leader of the House.

I asked him the million dollar question: Would he vote with the Labour motion? 

"Ma tarax, mhux ser nivvota maghhom" ('Can't you see that I will not vote with them?').

When I pressed him over what exactly he would do, he smiled. "Quote me on this, quote me on this," he said.

Franco Debono is a master of the monologue. He told me he was very hurt at the way I had attacked him. I picked up the phone and informed the MaltaToday newsroom what he had just said.

I know that when he entered parliament soon after, he was seen talking to Joseph Muscat. I can just imagine that Muscat must have asked him about the MaltaToday online story.

All I know is that soon afterwards, The Times were contacted by Debono. They then said that Debono had told them that he would not vote with government (MaltaToday said that he would not vote for the Labour motion).

There are two different versions, and the truth is that in both cases, Debono failed to say what he will do.

I phoned the other person who had sat with me and heard and witnessed Debono and asked him whether I had been hallucinating about what Debono had told me. He said that he was certain that Debono had said that he was not voting for the Labour motion.

Why can't Franco Debono just come clean and say what he is going to do? Later on, Debono phoned me and insisted that I had misunderstood him. I asked point blank what he was going to do when it came to vote.

He said that I would have to wait until tonight. 'Just impossible' would be an understatement.

When I think about Debono's relentless attack on Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici, I can understand his primary concerns. But I can't help but wonder: why the focus on Mifsud Bonnici? There are other ministers who have shortcomings, which are simply unforgivable.

The first to come to mind is George Pullicino - the father of the ODZ schemes and the mother of all our planning problems.  We have Dolores Cristina, an affable minister but one who has proven beyond any doubt her lack of vigour in reforming our education system.  Then there is Austin Gatt, the minister who gave birth to the public transport reform and captained the electricity and water tariffs.

And what shall we say about Tonio Fenech, and his scandalous episodes? I imagine the list of ministerial failings to be endless.

And yet, Debono has chosen to focus on Mifsud Bonnici, who has stubbornly stood his ground and showed us that he has no self-respect in the face of so much criticism.

But what Debono has achieved with the blessing of both Lawrence Gonzi and Joseph Muscat is prove just how both parties cannot see through his antics. When tonight he decides to abstain - as he is expected to do - he would have nailed the last nail in his coffin of credibility.

But he would have also lampooned the two political leaders. Lawrence Gonzi, for having proven to us that he loves power more than his love for the smooth administration of this government. And Joseph Muscat, for having been led to believe that Debono would bring down his own government.

This country needs to attend to its urgent needs. 

When Debono abstains tonight, we must start focusing on the real immediate needs of this country. 

We should only talk about change before the next general elections. Before that, we (the media) are duty bound to debate the urgent issues that need tackling, and start ignoring those who have wasted precious time for all the players involved.

avatar
To your title Saviour... because Joseph has taken a sidelines advisor on the quiet since 2009. Be aware of the Jekyll and Hyde nature here. It's personal objectives first. Franco is such a dummy. Joseph beware once he's done with you it will be your turn to follow the same route. He doesn't give a fig. Anyone's expendable. You won't be able to turn and point fingers then, he'll be gone. Tracks almost always covered, or serviced clean again. Almost no trail, but an investigative journalist of reasonable intelligence prepared to go back a few years will perhaps find it.
avatar
Saviour, you are forgetting one thing: it wasn't Franco Debono who presented the motion against Mifsud Bonnici. It was the PL. Your article shows however that, like everybody else, you are certain that it was because of Debono that the motion was presented. Labour speakers deny this but you don't believe them. Now, if a staunch (albeit temporary) Labour supporter like you does not believe the PL, one can imagine what credibility the party has among non-aligned voters.
avatar
Saviour, Carmelo was ill and Franco took the upper hand, though Carmelo claimed he was ill, yet kept his column on the paper of blog updated, that proofs Carmelo was not that ill. Carmelo was trying to catch up with what he never bothered to do these last four years. Franco knew that Pl had the intention of putting forward a vote of no confidence last August and as Pl were informed that CMB was not well they just shelved the motion. Franco thought that he could grab the front seat from CMB but found out CMB was part of the clique, so than realized he had no chance to replace CMB and started a campaign to oust CMB. He is the laziest and the weakest Minister amongst the clique, he overtook even Zammit Dimech post nicknamed as the Minister of Laziness, with so many things that should have been accomplished in the last four years but never materialized. CMB should be responsible for all these failures, not just one but a multitude.
avatar
Amen!
avatar
Excellent analysis as usual. However, the best service you can give to your readers is to delete the name Franco Debono from your vocabulary. We do not wish to be taken for a ride any longer and he is doing it becaus he is finding an accomodating media who reports every word adn gesture. This man has taken eveybody for a ride, he did it because he is a megalomaniac and loves the limelight and did it at the expense of a country thrown into anxiety. Pls stop mentioning this man.
avatar
well said Savior, that this buffon has led these two idiots by the nose, especially J Muscat.If the PL continues with this attitude and do not start being serious to tell the people what the plans are, I will copy this buffon, and I will abstain on voting.