Appeals Court rakes in favour of the Commissioner of Revenues
Malcolm Mifsud
The Court of Appeal held that the Court does not have the competence to determine whether the Revenues Commissioner had a title or not over the amount based on the evidence...
Distinction must be made between the merits of an executive title and the formality of an executive warrant
Malcolm Mifsud
The Court endorsed the argument that a party attacking an executive warrant with which such party is burdened had to make a distinction between the formality of an executive act...
Discrimination is the difference in treatment of the same situation
Malcolm Mifsud

In a judgment delivered on 5 December in Mark Muscat v HSBC, it was held...

In a judgment delivered on 5 December in Mark Muscat v...

Rent Regulation Board, not the courts, is competent to hear all cases concerning rent
Malcolm Mifsud

The First Hall of Civil Court decided it was not competent to hear cases concerning rent issues in the case of Joseph Sammut v Liliana Jalil

The First Hall of Civil Court decided it was not competent...

Court removes parental authority from disinterested father
Malcolm Mifsud

A judgement delivered on 21 November in LB v Dr Christopher Chircop and PL L...

A judgement delivered on 21 November in LB v Dr Christopher...

Period of prescription may be interrupted even after it elapses

The facts of the case of Joginder Singh Dhingsa v Anthony Grech et. revolved...

The facts of the case of Joginder Singh Dhingsa v Anthony...

Party cannot be in default if time period within which to reply has not elapsed
Malcolm Mifsud

In a family law dispute named AB v CB, the plaintiffs asked the court to remove the defendants' statement of defence and courter claim

In a family law dispute named AB v CB, the plaintiffs asked...

Parties may compete with different titles over the same properties
Malcolm Mifsud

In a judgement delivered in Joseph Camilleri and Michael Camilleri v John Mary...

In a judgement delivered in Joseph Camilleri and Michael...

The repossession of a property must be clearly mentioned as an action of spoliation
Malcolm Mifsud

Arnaud's mother lived in a property in Valletta but once she passed away, his sister changed the locks, not allowing him to enter

Arnaud's mother lived in a property in Valletta but...

When a customer tells a service provider to stop, it means stop
Malcolm Mifsud

The Small Claims Tribunal ruled that with the expiration of a TV contract, it...

The Small Claims Tribunal ruled that with the expiration of...

When one plea may cancel another
Malcolm Mifsud

A plea claiming that an action is time barred, may be cancelled if one pleads that the claim itself is overstated

A plea claiming that an action is time barred, may be...

Judicial review proceedings must commence within six months
Malcolm Mifsud

The First Hall of the Civil Courts refused to consider whether the suspension...

The First Hall of the Civil Courts refused to consider...

An agreement must be kept, come what may
Malcolm Mifsud

The Court of Appeal, presided by Mr Justice Anthony Ellul, ruled that an agreement of payment should be honoured, even if the services rendered were not...

The Court of Appeal, presided by Mr Justice Anthony Ellul,...

Serious lack of maintenance of rented premises may bring about eviction
Malcolm Mifsud

'When a tenant fails to perform maintenance, which leads to serious damage to the rented property, then the tenant may be evicted from that property'

'When a tenant fails to perform maintenance, which...

Harassment takes place when there is a multitude of incidents
Malcolm Mifsud

The Police V Tristan Tedesco - he was charged with having escaped from police...

The Police V Tristan Tedesco - he was charged with having...

Sentencing an under-aged person must be done with care
Malcolm Mifsud

The Magistrates Court held that when a youth is being sentenced, the court must...

The Magistrates Court held that when a youth is being...

Eviction cannot be blocked by the Court, if it has already been carried out
Malcolm Mifsud

The First Hall of the Civil Court turned down a warrant issue request of prohibitory injunction to block an eviction but the court marshals had already changed...

The First Hall of the Civil Court turned down a warrant...

Warrant of prohibitory injunction approved irrespective of special hypothec
Malcolm Mifsud

A Magistrate’s Court upheld an application for a warrant of prohibitory injunction, even though the applicant had a special hypothec in his favour

A Magistrate’s Court upheld an application for a...

When buyer discovers defect, he must take legal action within six months
Malcolm Mifsud

The Magistrates Court upheld a plea of prescription because the buyer of a car found out the defect well before the action was instituted

The Magistrates Court upheld a plea of prescription because...

Court rules that articles of law need not necessarily be mentioned at the conclusion of a judgment
Malcolm Mifsud

A judgment is not null and void if the Court fails to mention all the articles of law in its conclusion, but are mentioned in other parts of the judgment

A judgment is not null and void if the Court fails to...