Couple make up, magistrate scolds them for wasting his time

‘Every hearing costs €700’, Magistrate Carol Peralta tells couple summoned over domestic argument

Magistrate Carol Peralta
Magistrate Carol Peralta

A magistrate scolded a couple in court for having wasted the court's time and resources.

For the second day running, Magistrate Carol Peralta chastised the people appearing before him in his hall for wasting court time with their bickering.

The court scheduled to hear a case of a domestic incident between Josef Tabone, 26 of Hamrun, and Charlene Azzopardi, 25 of Mosta, that took place in May.

However, the couple summoned in court informed the magistrate there and then that they had forgave each other.

Upon hearing this, Peralta told off the couple for having wasted the court's time. "Every hearing costs €700, and if you saw the people waiting outside in the corridor, you'd know better than to use public service only to turn up in court and forgive each other."

Azzopardi gave a darting look to her mother, who was sitting next to her and rolled her eyes: "We had a normal and simple argument," she told the magistrate, "but she called the police."

Taking the witness stand, the mother told the court that she looked after the couple and their children. "It's not right that they constantly fight and argue in my house. I'm always stuck between them, and Tabone blames my daughter for all the arguments. I had had enough and I called the police," she told the court.

Peralta pointed at the police, his deputy registrar and the court reporters present in an admonishment: "You wasted all these people's time. If you're brought in my hall again I will fine you the total of these proceedings' costs."

avatar
Instead of congratulating the couple for making up they got scolded. What should the court gods get for taking 13 1/2 years on a simple court case? "Ordinary citizens" should not waste time but those not so ordinary can waste others both time and money. The not so ordinary can even take what doesn't belong to them and the ordinary have to pay for not the so ordinary. Justice is there for one and all the ordinary and for the not so ordinary.
avatar
Good for you Carol. It is about time that ordinary citizens do not waste time in Court and do not waste the Court's time. People who do so should be fined the cost of all the time so many people, witnesses included, have wasted.