[LIVE] Follow Tonio Fenech’s press conference on our live blog here

Follow our live blog from the PN headquarters of finance minister Tonio Fenech's press conference.

Tonio Fenech is fronting the Nationalist Party's offensive against Labour's energy package.
Tonio Fenech is fronting the Nationalist Party's offensive against Labour's energy package.

This press conference has ended. CLICK HERE to go the earliest post.

5:27pm Fenech says the investment in Delimara phase 2 (BWSC turbine) and the interconnector is part of the PN's plan to reduce energy prices, but also to get EU funds for a gas pipeline project that can further reduce costs.

5:26pm Fenech cannot answer a question by MaltaToday how much the report commissioned by KPMG has cost Enemalta.

5:24pm Fenech says that an offshore gas terminal would be funded by the EU because it would offer alternative pipeline connection to Europe from countries other than Russia, which currently supplies countries as far south as Italy. "So far we always studied a Malta-Sicily link for our needs, now we are considering this wider option. The difference is that our proposal connects us to Europe and qualifies us for EU funds, while Labour's proposal isolates us."

5:23pm MaltaToday's Jurgen Balzan has asked Fenech about the gas storage terminal project touted by the PN, and whether this has Qatari involvement.

5:16pm The KPMG presentation is ONLINE HERE on our Google Drive.

5:16pm "Labour is trying to make us swallow their line that this power station can be delivered in two years...  even a switchover itself requires time when going from one power station to the other. So if this project takes as long as the gas pipeline to construct, and the pipeline was suggested as the cheaper option even by Labour consultants DNV-Kema."

5:14pm Fenech says that 18 months would be the time-frame for the construction of a gas pipeline, but says there is the rest of the tendering process and other preliminary studies to take place before such a project can be effectively commissioned.

5:12pm Looks like Enemalta is uploading the KPMG report here *not yet online as we post*.

5:08pm Fenech is saying Labour's plan will mean chartering ships that are too large to carry smaller amounts of natural gas, and insists that specially built ships will have to be built, apart from being maintained throughout the years, to transport the consignments of natural gas to Malta. "Operating costs for these ships are even greater than the capital cost to build these ships - they probably cost €80 million each to build."

5:06pm "It is better to go for the gas pipeline a Nationalist government is working on, because it will deliver a cheaper cost of energy per unit produced."

5:05pm Fenech says large gas terminals away from land-based visibilty that can serve Europe fall under the EU's energy plan. He is referring to the PN's proposal to have an offshore natural gas terminal connecting Europe with a pipeline. "This is not a change in our policy, but a strategy to win European funds."

5:04pm "The KPMG report has been commissioned by Enemalta as it is within its right to do... and the report shows clearly that Labour's proposal will increase bills by 5%."

5:03pm Fenech is insisting that Labour's plan will cost €600 million and the PL should publish all health and safety, maritime and infrastructure reports if Labour is to be judged by the seriousness and detail of its plan.

5:01pm One TV (Labour) journalist is asking Fenech why KPMG advisors are not here to answers questions on this report, and whether the report has been financed by government. Fenech is qualifying his role: "I am still a minister... the report is published on the Enemalta website."

4:59pm Fenech says a detailed report from KPMG, available ont the Enemalta website (we cannot find it yet) shows that Labour's ambitious project will deliver higher costs for energy.

4:57pm The total cost of energy will increase by 5%, Fenech says - which translates directly into a 5% increase in prices.

4:53pm Fenech says the 9c6 per unit of energy produced by Labour's purported energy mix (40% from a gas powered 200MW power station, 40% from Delimara phase 2, and 20% from the interconnector) is incorrect: "The cost will be 12c5, apart from all operational costs, that is the cost of the distribution system, and the repayment of capital costs.

4:50pm "It is impossible to have this project completed in two years" - Fenech says, adding that a new 200MW power station "is not needed" when the government is already underway with plans for a 200MW underwater electricity interconnector.

4:49pm Again Fenech points out that a 10-year hedging agreement on gas is not possible due to the changes in market prices for natural gas, and that the only reason Labour is going for this option to import LNG into harbour to a gas terminal, is only due to shorter time-frames.

4:46pm Fenech says Labour's estimates "are out of mark" by €200 million, saying that the bills will have to reflect capital costs for the infrastructure required for the PL plan.

4:45pm Fenech said he will publish costings by auditors KPMG, which show Muscat's proposal will cost €105 for every €100 that people pay for their utility bills today.

4:44pm Finance minister Tonio Fenech is addressing on a press conference in which he will say that Labour's proposal for a gas terminal and new power station will raise energy bills, not make them cheaper.

avatar
One has to admire Gonzi's campaign advisory team. First Mr Fenech is made to believe he stands a chance in the race against Dr Busuttil only to be humiliatingly routed by the party's councilors (if Mr Fenech was honestly not aware of such a strong bias by the councilors he is a man to be pitied). Now he is being pushed to debate energy policies carrying the baggage of Enemalta's massive debts, the BWSE saga and various phantom energy pseudo initiatives. The message being sent seems to be - We might lose the argument on energy so we might as well profit from it and get rid of the man.
avatar
Fenech says the investment in Delimara phase 2 (BWSC turbine)........... Is the reduction being done through switching off some turbines??? and people would save money becuase they don't have electricity in their homes. U morru halluna ftit fil-paci. Dwar id-djun u d-deficits ?? x'sejrin naghmlu??? jawaq bhal ma kien qal George Bonello Du Puis ex Ministru tal-Finanzi "Id-dejn ihallsuh uliedna u ulied uliedna" Finanzi fis-sod. Eddie weghdiu GONZI SFREGI.
avatar
Gbajt nara wicc Tonio Fenech fuq it-TV;halqu l-hin kollu jghid biex inessi l-izbalji li ghamel hu fid-decizzjonijiet il-hziena li ha; u dan kif qed jahseb li jien niehu gost inhallas l-kontijiet second highest in Europe? Biex inpaxxi li dawk li hadu l-commission?+s??
avatar
Gonzipn has reached new heights! No distinction between partisan politics and government administrative agencies.
avatar
My guess (and I admit I'm not an expert so I might be completely wrong) is that this is a case of circular reasoning. The report says that the price rises mainly because of 'returns of capital investment'. But the PN is saying that the project costs €600 million, and so this report uses that figure. What this report says is that, if PN is right on the €600 million, then the cost will rise by 5%. However, if PL is to believed, then their plan still stands. If anything this report strengthens PL's propasal. It shows that even with the €600 million (and let's face it, that figure is definitely a highest-end figure, because it was calculated in just 2 days by Tonio Fenech trying to dismiss the proposal), elecricity prices would rise by just 5%. This means that if the cost is somewhere between what PN and PL are saying, electricity prices can be lowered (and air-pollution lessened).
avatar
KPMG. The company which gets most if not all of Tonio Fenech's contracts, if I remember correctly. Could they be thinking that a change of government could result in a loss of business for them ? I am only asking.
avatar
Tonio please shut up. Do not continue to make a fool of yourself. Your arguments have been shot down over and over again. Journalists should take this opportunity to ask Tonio to publish government's plans for an off-shore terminal to supply gas to Europe. He should also be asked why the PN govt bought a power station that works on HFO and which now needs an investment of €60 million to be changed to work on gas.