PN’s U-turn on gender quotas: pledges 40% quota for women on boards

After opposing EU law to put more women on top, the Nationalist Party is now pledging gender quotas.

The PN pledges to increase female representation on the board of directors.
The PN pledges to increase female representation on the board of directors.

After the Nationalist government opposed mandatory quotas for female participation at executive level on all government boards and public listed companies, the PN is now pledging to have, by 2020, 40% of all publicly-listed companies' board of directors composed of women.

In its electoral programme published yesterday evening, the PN pledged a future government would commit itself to "having at least a 40% female representation on the board of directors of public companies and entities by 2020 and encourage the private sector to follow suit".

The surprise U-turn - nonetheless much welcomed by women's organisations - follows a year in which the Nationalist government declared it would join a diplomatic push spearheaded by the United Kingdom to oppose a law that would introduce mandatory quotas for women on companies listed on the stock exchange.

Justice Minister Chris Said himself had argued that it would be "counterproductive for the EU to work towards developing legislative measures in terms of legally-binding quotas, given the very different situations and starting points in member states making it very difficult to foresee how a 'one-size-fits-all' solution can be implemented effectively across the EU."

Said had insisted the EU should stay out of such legislation and instead allow national governments to pursue their own equality measures.

Government's opposition to quotas had startled the Malta Confederation of Women's Organisation (MCWO) and the National Council of Women.

"The Government's decision to oppose the boardroom gender quotas comes as shocking news to the National Council of Women," executive member Roselyn Borg had said. "We urge the government to rethink its position and support the quota system. Gender balance is long overdue and opposing it is surely unacceptable."

On the other hand, both the Labour Party and Alternattiva Demokratika had declared their position in favour of the policy, with PL describing it as "a necessary evil" and AD "a necessity to overcome barriers".

The Maltese government says it has already taken the initiative to ensure that women are well represented on boards and committees in the public sector, and it has introduced tax breaks for mothers returning to the labour market.

A cursory glance at the public sector's main corporations and government-owned companies also indicates that the presence of women on boards is probably already at 40% on average.

But within the Maltese private sector, 'board-ready' women are not adequately represented.

The European Commission says that according to the EU Labour Force Survey, Malta has over 1,000 women (25%) in the private sector who are directors and CEOs or managers of small enterprises, compared to over 4,000 men who have the same roles in private business.

And yet, nearly 60% of university graduates are women, a heartening figure dampened by the fact that Malta has the lowest rate of female participation in the labour market of all the EU member states: 34% of the national workforce.

avatar
Priscilla Darmenia
@Karl Consiglio / If I heard Simon correctly, he declared that he agreed that ministers should resign only if there is a vote of no confidence in parliament. This means that unless there is another Franco Debono in parliament, a minister will never loose a vote of no confidence in parliament. Yes Simon is showing early what he is; a GonziPN clone.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
With Gonzi U-TURN!
avatar
So now we're no longer afraid that the EU will stop thinking Malta is credible if we change our policy? At this rate, with a few more U-turns, Gonzi will no longer know whether he's coming or going. I'd like to know what the employers and the Chamber of Commerce and Industry have to say about this: Gonzi has left them up the creek without a paddle! Or does promising it by 2020 mean that this will be another long-term promise that will be implemented grudgingly or forgotten along the way? Tell us which, Mr. Par Idejn Sodi.
avatar
Simon Busuttil has been around long enough! It's just a fact that he is another Mr. U-turn. How did he vote on gender equality quotas in the EU?
avatar
As far as incan remember Gonzi and his speakers told hs svdral times that minimium wage earners do not pay tax! Is this anipother U turn or PN copying one of Musacts bad advicez? U hallina Gonz
avatar
Unless you going to expand a bit on your argument then just speak for yourself Firillu! How can you speak that way of Simon if he's only just been appointed and he's still fresh?
avatar
NOTE THE CATCH WORD "BY 2020". THIS MEANS THAT THE PN IS NOT EVEN PROMISING TO START DOING SOMETHING ABOUT WOMEN PARTICIPATION BEFORE THE NEXT LEGISLATURE IS FINISHED IN 5 YEARS TIME AND THE YET NEXT LEGISLATURE IS 3 YEARS GONE!!! WHAT A FANTASTIC PROMISE!!! WOMEN OF MALTA UNITE TOGETHER. THE PN IS PROMISING YOU A BIG FAT NOTHING DURING THE NEXT 5 YEARS - THEY ARE ONLY PROMISING TO PAY LIP SERVICE SO THAT THEY GET YOUR VOTE AND THEN THEY DUMP YOU. BUT OF COURSE WE ARE ACCUSTOMED NOW TO THESE PROMISES THAT LEAD TO THE MOON AND LEAVE YOU THERE.
avatar
It is far from a U-Turn. There is a difference between making gender quotas mandatory to get to a higher percentage and making it easier for women to be part of the working world as a strategy to increase participation. The mandatory option is offensive, the latter alternative is encouraging.
avatar
Lawrence Gonzi is going to pledge that if he is elected he will change his name officially to Joseph Muscat. He will also dye his hair red. In the coming meetingshe will wave a red scarf, chant "Malta Taghna Lkoll" and then urge his supporters to belt out the Labour anthem. So much for the PN being the real thing and others copycats!
avatar
Qatt ma taf fejn int ma Gonzi w Simon
avatar
Ser ikollna U-turns galore minn nahha tal-PN. Imbasta jippruvaw jahtfu l-voti. Imbaghad wara ngibu elf skuza ghaliex l-proposti li ghamlu ma rrexxewx...is-soltu. Kif jista' xi hadd jafdhom?
avatar
GonziPn voted against women quota in European Parliamnet and today it is saying it wants 40% of women on boards? Ara vera ghal poter ibieghu kollox: ank lilhom infushom! Program elettorali copy cat u a la carte'!