Updated | PN want GWU boss to resign after releasing secret recording [LISTEN]

GWU secretary-general Tony Zarb heard talking of union giving companies ‘a push’ when it comes to government tenders.

GWU secretary-general Tony Zarb
GWU secretary-general Tony Zarb

Nationalist party organ In-Nazzjon has released an edited, secret recording on YouTube which purportedly has General Workers Union secretary-general Tony Zarb hinting that the union can influence government tendering if Labour is elected to power.

The recording, edited in such a manner that it does not deliver a straight flow of the conversation, appears to capture GWU officials, amongst them Tony Zarb, speaking to a 'mediator' or a company owner, of the benefits of unionisation for his employees, as well as favourable treatment in the GWU organ.

In-Nazzjon claims the recording shows Tony Zarb portraying the union as being helpful to companies in government tenders, especially if Labour are elected to power. In it, a colleague of Zarb is heard saying that the union can give "worthy tenders" a "push", while Zarb himself points out that with company employees unionised with the GWU, the company would avoid bad press in the GWU organ l-orizzont.

In-Nazzjon claims that the recording also shows Tony Zarb saying that the government, especially with Labour in power, would be particularly sensitive to attacks from the union should a favoured company - in this case, a company whose employees are GWU members - did not receive a government tender.

According to In-Nazzjon, the conversation has been deliberately edited and the YouTube recording is only an excerpt of the entire conversation.

"This shows clearly the kind of pressure that the GWU puts on contractors or people in business, especially if Labour is in power," In-Nazzjon wrote in its news story today.

In an initial reaction, the GWU condemned what it termed the "misleading reporting" from the PN media of the meeting between Zarb and the company representative.

"This meeting was intended at addressing the problem of precarious employment. The PN has broadcast selective and edited excerpts of a private conversation in a bid to damage the GWU. The GWU considers this to be a continuation of the PN's attacks against it and against the interests of workers, and raises doubts as to whether the PN sees the GWU as a dignified partner in industrial relations."

The GWU said it was reserving the right to take "all steps necessary" with respect to the PN media's report.

On its part, the PN said in a statement that the GWU would be a "privileged partner" to a new Labour government. "Tony Zarb must resign immediately... the union's status as a privileged partner would put other workers' unions and their members at a disadvantage. A union that gives 'a push' to company tenders instead of workers shows a scandalous attitude of 'I'll scratch your back if you scratch mine'."

avatar
The more spin, GonziPN & Co are doing, the more obvious it is becoming that the current leadership is coming to its end. “The news media is being utilized as a political tool of suppression and propaganda by those in power, and propaganda is psychological in nature. Full and half –truths and utter misinformation, it’s arrogant and very commercial strategy that is implemented because it appeals to emotions, fear being the main one relentless talk of national security, personal and community safety, can trigger childhood insecurity indoctrinated views of authority” , TERESA STOVER Good try Paul & Co, maybe next time you do succeed!
avatar
Wow - what a scoop. They caught Zarb stuffing his face with food and talking crap! Pooh! Gonzi you are just pathetic!
avatar
Il-PN qal lil Tony Zarb biex jirrezenja mmedjetament. Tad-dahq jew tal-biki ma nafx jiena. Ma jafux tal-Partit Nazzjonalista li l-kliem iqanqal imma l-ezempju jqaxkar. Kemm il-rizenja rajna fil-PN dawn l-ahhar 5 snin? Rajna 2 ghax gew sfiducjati fil-Parlament u ma rajna xejn izjed. Kieku l-affarijiet li graw f'dan il-Gvern graw gewwa nghidu ahna l-Ingliterra kieku 3/4 tal-ministri kienu jirrezinjaw u mhux biss minn ministri imma anke minn deputati ghax hekk imorru l-affarijiet. U min fuq b'wicc helu ta' Nazzjonalisti li ghandhom jigu jitolbu r-rizenja ta' dak u l-iehor bi dritt. Morru u halluna u ddejquniex izjed baqalna xahar b'ilgri jghaddi halli nehilsu minkom. Tony Zarb zomm sod ghax ghandek principji sodi u gusti mhxu bhal tal-PN.
avatar
childish tactics and cheap tricks,all i heard was part of a so called private conversation regarding workers rights.
avatar
TO RECORD A PERSON WITHOUT HIS CONSENT IS A CRIMINAL OFFENCE UNDER THE DATA PROTECTION ACT AND THE GONZIPN MACHINERY SHOULD BE TAKEN TO TASK BY THE DATA PROTECTION COMMISSIONER. TO DELIBERATELY EDIT AN UNAUTHORIZED AND ILLEGAL RECORDING IS ANOTHER ACT OF CORRUPTION WHICH, WHATEVER THE CONTEXT, IS ANOTHER CRIMINAL OFFENCE. NOTHING CAN JUSTIFY SUCH CRIMINAL ACTIVITY AND THE SIMPLE ADMISSION THAT THIS HAS BEEN DONE SHOULD BE ENOUGH EVIDENCE FOR CRIMINAL ACTION TO BE TAKEN.
avatar
It is utterly disgusting to see what the PN is trying to do! I think that there are persons in the country that are extremely worried when the PL is going to be elected!
avatar
Nara dawk l-affarijiet nibda nahseb x'sejrin jitilfu in-Nazzjonalisti u x'ferh ta genn ghandhom biex jaraw x'jghamlu biex iggrldu wiehed ma iehor biex FORSI igawdu huma. Dawn jaslu ghal kollox. Gonzi qal li jiggieled il-KORRUZZJONI, hahahahahahah Mhux ahjar nghamlu il-"Whistles Blower's ACT malajr kemm jista ikun qabel jibdew jaharbu in-nies mill-pajjiz? Kulhadd ghandu ihallas dak dovut huwa min huwa "Mill-akbar RAS f'dan il-pajjiz sa l-ixghar ras. Qedin niftemu Dottore ?
avatar
but seriously, apart from the il ost++, illos+++ , what's all the fuss about? Is that a SCOOP?!
avatar
I have a feeling that this is an edited recording and,therefore, I seriously doubt how genuine it is. I wouldn't be surprised that politics has stooped so low. If this would turn out to be the case, then it's criminal tempering.
avatar
Din ghogbitni: "....izda li tali dikjarazzjonijiet ta' ideali, ideat u drawwiet komuni ndawruhom f'fatti f'pajjizna meta c-cirkuostanzi jitolbu li min JIZGARRA JIRRIZENJ u JIRTIRA mill-hajja pubblika" Editorjal 'L-ORRIZONT' illum il-HAMIS, 7 ta' FRAR, 2013. Dawn kliem hiereq mil-erba kmamar li ghandkom f'qalbkom, sur Zarb! ISSA DAQSHEKK.....trid tisma min kliemkom stess. CALLL IT A DAY!
avatar
Priscilla Darmenia
this recording seems to be heavely edited. where is the full version of the recording? I think it is another PM spin by manipulating bits and pieces of a recording to make us believe what they want us to believe.
avatar
Since the company representative went in to the meeting with the deliberate intention to record it (obvious bad faith in a private meeting), this "scoop" for the PN becomes valueless unless they release the unedited version to show that the incriminating statements were made voluntarily by Zarb and not under pressure from what could have been a PN agent provocateur. "Worthy" or "favoured" companies in Maltese could just as easily mean companies that had a proper collective agreement or did not utilise short-term contracting. The PL has already made it clear that it wants to stamp out such bad practice in the services industry and that dubious companies would be black-listed when tendering for government contracts (such as is done in the US and most civilised countries, incidentally).
avatar
Mr Zarb...don't bring up 'silly' excuses. According to your to-day's paper editorial, people caught in such circumstances MUST RESIGN! Giving 'pushes' in government tender, is awful!! Taking 'all steps necessary' will mean, a libel which will be decided FOUR YEARS from now. NO, you can't stand their not even for four more hours!!!
avatar
First of all the GWU is not the PL. This is of paramount importance, especially to those who have a habit of recalling the past. Secondly, the recording is heavily edited - what has kept Net TV from giving us the whole recording? As it is, certain wording doesn't make sense because the conversation is articulated, and many expression could be taken out of context. Finally, as Joseph Muscat has said this morning, only he and his spokesmen are authorised to speak of government tendering should the PL win the election. The GWU are no longer PL spokesmen.