Labour leader plans to stop local warden ‘racket’ in councils reform

Stark warning to Labour incumbents in March 2012 council elections: ‘no place for candidates who are on the side of the bureacracy.’

Opposition leader Joseph Muscat will embark on a reform of the way the local wardens system is being financed by local councils, in his strongest declaration yet at the way the councils are managing taxpayers’ money.

Writing in General Workers Union daily l-orizzont, Muscat strongly hinted that he will stop the “racket” being subsidised by citizens where “the bulk of the cash received by councils is going... to two companies.”

Muscat referred to PQs tabled by Labour MP Justyne Caruana, in which no minister could reply as to where €4 million in fines paid up between January 2010 and March 2011 had been distributed amongst councils and private contractors.

“The days of big fish taking up everything are over... I’m standing up to this subsidised racket and no unspoken agreement will stop me.”

Wardens are provided by private firms and then farmed out to local councils, which are regionally grouped in nine ‘joint committees’. The three warden agencies – Guard & Warden, Sterling Security and Aurelia Asset Protection – manage the allocation of wardens as determined by the joint committee. Datatrak IT Services provides the technical infrastructure and support to sustain the process management.

The revenue from wardens’ tickets and speed camera fines are pooled together, from which the wardens and IT expenses are then deducted. The surplus is then divided among councils in proportion to the number of fines collected within their locality.

However, mayors have previously complained to MaltaToday that their councils were not reaping anything from the system.

Birkirkara mayor Michael Fenech Adami claimed his council raked in nothing, while Lija mayor Ian Castaldi Paris described the warden system as a burden on the council. Mqabba council was forced to pay €10,000 in 2008 because it did not receive enough cash from the fines.

In another stark warning, Joseph Muscat also indicated he will not be supporting Labour candidates and incumbents in the March 2012 local elections that “want to keep working in the present system where councils have become extensions of the government’s bureaucracy. Their time is up.”

MaltaToday understands that Muscat is planning on vetting candidates’ lists and that he will not approve “persons whose place is not with Labour’s candidates.”

Joseph Muscat has referred to a minority of councillors who have built a “wall of bureaucracy that has turned them into another government department… Sometimes I have been in a surreal situation in trying to elicit a simple answer from these people as to why a road was not completed or whose responsibility road mending was.”

The party has had its fair share of council problems, with Labour councillors forcing the resignation of Fgura mayor Darren Marmarà and more recently when Mosta mayor Paul Chetcuti Caruana ordered some six council employees to tear up a page from the council magazine featuring an article penned by fellow Labour councillor Josette Agius Decelis, which referred to a series of PQs on Mosta roads tabled by her husband, Labour MP Anthony Agius Decelis.

“These elections are going to be very hard for Labour... I can play the hypocritical game and use the elections as an electoral ploy. Or we can be honest without ourselves and try and change things,” Muscat said in his l-orizzont piece.

Muscat also said he was mindful that his route is “risky” and might cost him the local council elections in March 2012.

MORE Dispensing favours - are local councils the new patrons?

avatar
U daphnie Tonin? Se thallini bil-kurzita?
avatar
Kull tip ta racket huwa hazin. Ghalhekk niskanta kemm hawn min johodha bi kbira li xi hadd jixtieq jeqred il hazin. Tghid ikun hemm min ser jingidem mit tnehhija ta dawn ir-rackets jew sempliciment nikkritikaw ghax hareg biha JM?
avatar
L-indixxiplina gejja minn fuq. Naqbel mieghek. Imma meta l-Mosta pe kien hemm camera u kienet twahhal ic-cirazzjonijiet tghidx xi plejtu kien isir. Malli tela' kunsill laburista din il-camera tnehhiet! Min jaf kienku l-warden icapcaplek xi citazzjoni kemm tohrog twerzaq li Gonzipn qed jislihna. Ghax ma tghidx li l-ipokrisija hija ikbar mill-injoranza ta' xi whud.
avatar
Imma din l-indixxiplina u nuqqas ta' kontabilita' mhux minn fuq gejja Giovaninno? Iz-zghir jaghmel kif jara li qieghed jaghmel il-kbir. Min hu indixiplinat mod u min iehor. Il-huta min rasha tinten. U flimkien kollox possibli. Ergajna koppi!
avatar
@Ghawdxi ta' veru: Jien ilni mnaghmel suggeriment, imma ghalxejn: Overspeeding, uzu tal-mobalj waqt sewqan.....l-ewwel darba multa ta' E 5000 u t-tieni darba nikkonfiskalek il-karozza. Kontravenzjonijiet ohra: tella' l-multi li dak li jkun jahsibha darbtejn jekk jidholx go one way, jjipparkjax hazinm ecc. Infurzar strett u mhux kulhadd jaqa' u jqum. Il-Mosta haw car park ma genb il-knisja PRECIS quddiem l-ghassa. Min johrog mill-park ghandu ERBA' tabelli kbar li ma jistax idur lejn il-lemin. Bilforx lejn ix-xellug. Ejjew qattghu mftit hin hemm u taraw x'gharukaza...ezatt quddiem l-ghassa da. Morru l-pjazza ta' BNirkirkara kuljum u specjalment l-Erbgha u l-Gimgha...Taraw b'ghjnajekom tridu ghax inkella ma tifhmux. Ejjew il-pjazza tal-Mosta quddiem il-knsija...Morru fejn tridu u taraw id-dizordni u qiesu qatt ma gara xejn. Imbaghad nitkazaw ghax warden jaghti citazzjoni! Anqas nafu ezatt x'irridu. Kulhadd jiftahar "ghax barra, ghax barra.......irridu l-warden jaghti citazzjonijiet, imma lil haddiehor mhux lilna...
avatar
flok tiktbu biex tikritikaw u tajru lill-xulxin, Nissugerilkom iktbu u iproponu xi haga utli kif ghamilt jien fuq dan is-suggett. Iktbu u ghidu x'sistema ahjar tahsbu li f'Malta jista ikollna biex id-dixxiplina u is-serjeta fit-toroq taghna ma jonqsux. Jien aktar qabel ghidt li ghandhom jitnehhew il-gwardjani lokali u minflokhom ghandna insahhu it-taqsima tat-traffiku tal-korp tal Pulizija u jiehdu over il-pulizija minflok il-gwardjani, Ghidt ukoll li ghandha tidhol is-sistema tal-punti biex bil-mod il-mod jitnehhew xuffiera bullies u slavagg milli ikomplu isuqu. Ghidu x'tahsbu dwar l-ahjar sistema li jista ikollna biex bil-multi li jingabru jithallsu il-pagi tal-pulizija u il-kumplament kollu imur biex jintefqu mill-kunsilli lokali u ma jmorrux fi profitti ghand xi kumpanija privata. Hbieb ieqfu ajru lill-xulxin u ipruvaw ikkontribwixxu xi idea tajba fuq dan is-suggett ghall-gid. Insellmilkom.
avatar
U min n'hux taht dan il-gvern? Ovjament hlief tal-kikka.
avatar
Miskin!!!!!!!!!!!!
avatar
Il-fairy God mother, big brother Giovannino.
avatar
Din min kitibhielek, ras?
avatar
Scusami caro professore Giovannino Einstein DeMartino. Non sono all'altezza di Sua Maesta e la Sua Grandezza..
avatar
Kemm taf lingwi.......perfett tiktibhom!
avatar
Keep cool Giovannino...cool and relaxed kien jghid xi hadd. Kiekul kull aggettiv ingurjuz li tfajjar f'dawn il-blogs issarafhom f'voti, Kieku (with a capital K) il-profezzija cajtiera ta' Wistin Gatt propabli tirnexxi. Imma kif taf int, Giovannini, kieku w kien qatt ma iltaqghu flimkien. Bouna notte egreggio.
avatar
Jien ma' l-irgiel qed nitkellem PlPn mhux mal-vavi. Balalu!
avatar
Giovannino...u s-serduq idden ghal tlett darbiet....
avatar
John Smith Nirrepeti ghax hafna drabi haw qalu li jien hrigt kandidat kemm-il darba u ma tlajt qatt...Mhux veru. Kemm -ildarba indirizzawni bhala s-sindku tal-Mosta. Mhux veru. Jien lis-Sur Kenneth DeMartino anqas biss nafu u jien ma ghandi ASSOLUTAMENT x'naqsam xejn mal-wardens. Issa jekk ma trid x temmen KUN RAGEL int u giddibni mal-qarrejja. Semplici u nispera li ma tisparixxix bhalma jaghmlu hafna ohrajn meta ngibhom darhom malhajt. ( Kieku kien hemm xi relazzjoni mas-Sur Kenneth ibqa' zgur li ma kontx nisthi nghidha. Imma mhux il-kaz.
avatar
Giovann, m'intiex preciz u m'iniex sodisfatt. Jien qatt ma ghidt li inti kont sindku jew li kont kandidat tal-PN, ma staqsejteks ghalihom ghax naf li ma kontx. Pero qed tinheba wara subghajk. Daqs kemm jien ma ghandi x'naqsam xejn ma t-tifel ta hija. Anzi inti kkwalifikajta bli-"assolutament". Nerga nghidlek, trid tqarraq bina nahseb. BTW, ma fiha xejn hazin ta' ghax dak li semmejt inti ghandi rispett lejh. Imma rridu nkunu sincieri u onesti ahna stess qabel naghtu titli li jiguna f'mohhna lill ohrajn.
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
@Demartino. Jekk tifli sew il-kummenti, issib li kkoregejt ruhi.
avatar
@ neil Zammit...nahseb INT ma fhimtx sewwa dak li qrajt. JIEN u mhux Joseph Muscat semma' t-tnehhija tal-wardens. "Sewwa qed jghidu xi whud" ktibt jien. Bongu Smith: Nahseeb li ktibt 20 darba jien u nirrepeti ghall-beneficcju ta' dawk li jdumu ma jifhmu bil-Malti: 1. Jien qatt ma kont sindku ta' mkien. 2. Jien qatt ma kont kandidat ghall-parlamemnt. 3. Jien ma ghandi x'naqsam assolutament xejn mas-Sur Kenneth deMartino tal-gwardjani lokali. Sodisfatt? Salgister They ARE mhux is.
avatar
Giovann.DeMartino mhux qed jghid li se jnehhi l-wardens. fejn qed taqra hekk? Hu qed jghid li jrid inehhi il-burokrazija li tigi mal-wardens u il-flus li igbru huma jmur ghal kunsill biex jiranga ir-rahal li jiehu hsieb. Ma nafx kif taqraw haga u tifmu mija ohra jien. Irelevanti ma liema partit izzom.
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
Correction: They're not they's (mistype).
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
@Antoine Vella. Count Your Chickens Before they's HATCHED not LAID!
avatar
Bongu Demartin, haga wahda nixtieq minghandek dalghodu, ghall beneficcju ta dawk li inti ma tixbax tghajjar u tinsolenta. Tista tghidilna please jekk f'din l-issue inti ghandekx xi interess dirett, bhall nghidu ahna xi hadd jigi minnkekk konness mal-wardens. Jien naf, imma nippretendiha minghandek la tghid li inti onestissimu. Bongu Antoine, xi tfuh dalghodu. Ghidllna jekk €4m unaccounted for humiex racket. Jekk ma ndunajtx b'dan ir-racket veru tifhem biss fill-gur u l-pastard.
avatar
What Joseph Muscat really means is that he wants to set up a Labour "racket". . . They haven't yet won the elections and are already sharing the spoils between them - in politics it's called counting chickens before the eggs are laid.
avatar
Sewwa qed jghidu xi whud. Joseph, please, nehhi l-wardens, nehhi li speed cameras, nehhi l-pulizija tat-traffiku...it-tabelli m'hemmx ghalfejn tnehhihom ghax kulhadd jinjorhom.......nehhi kollox halli nigu qiesna gol-gungla.
avatar
Adopting the policy of eliminating bureaucracy and rackets is a step in the right direction. . This policy shouldn’t stop there; it should be extended to all government structures and entities.This government has lost all direction in areas like accountability and good governance; the entire system of government is geared at giving advantage and privilege to the connected few. Appointing people on account of merit, with a clear mandate is a nonexistent concept for this government. We’ve come to a point that this administration never speaks in terms of capability and performance, its only loyalty, insders and connections that matter. . If the PL extends these policies it should appeal to people that never voted for the PL. In my view, this goverment is just for the few, the rest are out of the loop and fed up with this style of government.
avatar
Jien ma naqbel xejn mas-sistema tal-gwardjani lokali ghax dawn ghandhom is-snien ma xi hadd li jkun kwiet u forsi ikun ghamel xi kontravenzjoni zghir pero huma bla sahha ma minn hu arroganti, pastaz, perikoluz u salvagg fis-sewqan. Jiena nahseb illi il-gwardjani ghandhom jitnehhew, pero minflok ghandha tissahhah it-taqsima tat-traffiku fil-korp tal-pulizija u ikunu il-pulizija li jiehdu hsieb id-dixxiplina u l-ordni fit-toroq . Pero il-pulizija ghanhom ikunu fizikament fit-toroq u ma jhallux id-dizordni issehh bhall ma jigri perezempju fi pjazza san frangisk u f'postijiet ohrajn f'ghawdex fejn tirrenja l-arroganza minn hafna xufiera. Nemmen illi fil-pajjiz ghandha tidhol ukoll is-sistema tal-penalitajiet bil-punti ukoll ghax b'hekk biss nistghu inwarrbu darba ghall-dejjem il-bullies u il-cowboys mit-toroq. J'alla issir riforma f'dan il-qasam biex minn ikun haqqu jigi ikkastigat ikun ikkastigat bis-serjeta. Pero jekk innehhu il-gwardjani ghall-skop ta voti ghax gejja xi elezzjoni u ma nsahhux bis-serjeta sistema ohra bhall ma ipproponejt allura ikun ahjar nibqghu kif ahna milli il-bullies u il-cowboys isibu aktar fejn jimirhu.
avatar
Dr Muscat, start NOW by ordering those local councils where there is a PL majority to scrap the wardens systems NOW. ** If PL leads the way the PN will follow. ** Gove the lead. ** Scrap the wardens system.
avatar
Hekk kif qieghed fil-venja ghax ma jaghmilx PQ forsi jippublikaw l-kuntratti tax-xoghol tal-haddiema bazuzli li hemm jahdmu gol-kunsilli kemm barra u kemm gewwa.Ix-xibka tal-burokrazija hija filtru mehtieg biex dak li jkun, bil-fors irid imur jitkarrab biex dak li hu bi dritt jiehdu bi pjacir. Ovjament wara jigi mitlub jew misruq il vot.
avatar
Get rid of the wardens system. ** They are only there to milk the drivers to fatten the pockets of the private wardens companies.
avatar
Its a racket and its high time someone puts a stop to it. If Muscat can do it - then more power to him.
avatar
This is the difference between the PL and the PN. Joseph Muscat looks at the future and convinces me that he really wants to change things. Lawrence Gonzi is stuck in the past. He put us all in a mess and he does not know how he is going to get us out of it.
avatar
@Giovann DeMartino, Iva wara l-haxi ta' shabekk se jkollu bicca xoghol iebsa mhux hazin.
avatar
@Giovann DeMartino, Iva wara l-haxi ta' shabekk se jkollu bicca xoghol iebsa mhux hazin.
avatar
Insomma se jkollu bicca xoghol verament iebsa Joseph!
avatar
Nahseb huma hsibijiet tajbin dawn li qed jghid Dr. Muscat. Nixtieq nistaqsi x qed jaghmel il partit biex jattira nies kwalifikati biex johorgu ghal kunsill? Nifhem l iskola mhux kollox biss nahseb li ghandu jkun hemm tahlita ta persuni mhux bhal kunsill tal Marsa li hemm il maggoranza lanqas o level standard ma ghandhom. Il PL se jaghmel yardstick biex jara li l kunsilli immexija min sindki laburisti ma jispicawx gvern iehor li jonfqu bl amment imbghad ihallas ta warajhom?
avatar
Prosit u prosit , ghax dawn saru sangisugi tac-cittadin specjalment meta certi kunsilli dahhlu dawk il-hnizrijiet ta' By Laws li jiddiskriminaw kontra cittadini li mhux mil-lokal taghhom .Dawn introducew sistema ta' parkegg riservat ghar-residenti biss . Mhux hekk biss , talli ghamlu wkoll sistema ta' parkegg bil-hin ghall dawk li mhux residenti tal-lokal .Din hija sistema li tiddiskrimina bejn cittadin u iehor . Hija wkoll kontra li-spirtu ta' dak li tghid il-kostituzzjoni , fejn tghid li ma ghanda ssir ebda ligi li tiddiskrimina bejn ic-cittadini . Ghalhekk fl-opinjoni tieghi dawn il-By Laws la huma kontra dak li tghid il-kostituzzjoni huma wkoll illegali . Diga kien hemm diversi sentenzi tal-qorti li qalu li dawn huma diskriminatorji , izda bil-wicc tost kollu , kemm il-gvern kif ukoll certi Kunsilli Lokali gew jaqghu u jqumu min dak li ipprononzjat il-qorti . Ghalhekk jiena nappella lill dawk kollha li jaqilghu citazzjoni ta' dan it-tip biex jikkontestaha , u jekk xorta wahda jigu immultati quddiem it-tribunal , iressqu appell quddiem il-Qorti u jiggieldu ghad-drittijiet taghhom u wkoll biex dawn il-By Laws li huma diskriminatorji u illegali jigu mnehhija . Jien hekk qed naghmel u dan nibqa naghmlu sakemm niehu ragun anke jekk ikun hemm bzonn li niftah kawza kostituzzjonali .
avatar
I hope that while you are at it, you reduce the number of local councils from 50+ to 4 and elect subcommittees instead. 1 in gozo and 3 in Malta are more than enough. 5 councilors in Fontana!!!!!! 1 for every 60 residents?
avatar
Well said. Once the whole system is pulled apart : Well done.
avatar
About bloody time! There really is a racket. Wardens should be nationalised and their remit widened to other duties. All they seem to be doing is slapping fines for no parking, use of mobile phones and seat belts, overspeeding using cameras - basically the easy stuff where they do not have to confront the motorist. Then all other traffic offences such as dangerous driving, overspeeding in built-up areas, crossing of lanes, no use of indicators, double parking of delivery vans, etc. are ignored because they do not have the gall to face the motorist. I do not know of any similar system in Europe where the wardens are a cartel of companies. Totally unheard of. In Italy wardens do a wide range of duties, over and above traffic offences. They check check trading licences, they check sanitation to certify that a place is habitable, etc. They are also a part of the community. People know them by name and they build rapport with the community. Besides, by nationalising, these people should be in a better position to educate people.
avatar
Whilst many of us have become dispossessed, a few good blue eyed fellas, struck it rich! Police officers should suffice; at least one can argue logically with them. No more money grabbing by stealth!
avatar
Why not give local councils their independence and cut the umbilical chord from the local parties?
avatar
IMbaghad biex jilghabu tal-helwin issaqsu minn fejn ser igib il-flus il-PL biex imexxi. Barra l-fatt li ma jghamilx progetti kapitali bla bzonn bhal bieb il-belt, l-akwarju u l-parlament iwaqqaf l-emorogija ta' flus li sejrin fil-bwiet tal-privat, fejn issib individwi li ftit ilu lanqas ghaxja ta' lejl ma kellhom u llum farru u jigru bil-karozzi lussuzi u yachts. Ghira wiehed jistaqsi, IVA ghira ghal gustizzja li trid tidher qed issir.
avatar
Keep it up. Hekk irid jisma kull cittadin honest Malti u Ghawdxi, hu min hu, hu x'inhu, hu ta' liema inklinazzjoni politika hu (ovjament jew hi). Il-maggoranza flagranti u assoluta tal-poplu Malti imxebbgha sa ruh omma b'din il-korruzzjoni kostituzzjonizzata u aaprovat permezz ta' ligijiet strambi u vvizjati. Hekk ghandha tkun il-politika. Politika tas-sewwa. Imbaghad certament li Is-sewwa jirbah zgur!
avatar
testing
avatar
Go go go Joseph, time for the sharks to be hooked and skinned. Like it has already been mentioned the Mater Dei car park should be handed over to the hospital authorities and the money made goes to help the Health Sector. One way to sustain the free medical system.
avatar
Other rackets that need to be stopped on a national level.....the hospital car park, security at the hospital and various govt depts, contractors providing care workers and nurses etc etc etc