Court rules Caruana Galizia 'slandered' former PL President

In a judgement delivered by the Civil Court, blogger Daphne Caruana Galizia was ordered to compensate former PL President Manwel Cuschieri for slander.

The case goes back some 12 years when Cuschieri hosted a radio show, ‘Tajjeb li Tkun Taf’ on One radio.

Cuschieri had filed a libel case against Caruana Galizia after he felt aggrieved by comments levelled against him in an article she had written in The Malta Independent on 21 October 1999. The article was titled ‘Vote, or be fined’.

In its judgement, the Court presided by Justice JR Micallef dismissed Caruana Galizia's defence was not 'correct in fact and law' and therefore ruled that she had damaged Cuschieri's reputation. She was ordered to pay €950 in damages to Cuschieri. Caruana Galizia has to also pay legal expenses.

In her article, the blogger had described Cuschieri as “Mr Evil”, “hate creed”, “sowed anti-Semitism” and “seditious agenda”. Cuschieri had described this as "character assassination."

Earlier this year Caruana Galizia was also found of criminal libel against Labour deputy leader Anglu Farrugia

avatar
Do keep at it Daphne. Let us finally enjoy.
avatar
In praise of Daphne Caruana Galizia and to set the record straight. (1) She was fired from the TOM. (2) These libel fines are paid from a fund that EFA awarded as a contract in the amount of 30000 pounds. (3) Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder but if you can describe Daphne's neck as sexy, you need help to rediscover your sexuality. More so if you can get close enough to be sexually aroused, you might need a witch's love potion to finish your conquest. (4) One of her best sports discipline is throwing china plates made in china, hopefully she will represent Malta in next year's olympics. The best compliment anyone can give Daphne is this. AUTHOR: John Dryden (1631–1700) QUOTATION: I can enjoy her while she ’s kind; But when she dances in the wind, And shakes the wings and will not stay, I puff the prostitute away IT WOULD BE INTERESTING READING HER OPINION TOMORROW.
avatar
someone says she has beautiful neck below. It's because she is always raising her neck too high to see what is going on in other people's businesses.
avatar
Why not give her some jail time. She keeps slandering people and just gets a small fine. ISn't it time for her to serve jail time.
avatar
the boomerangs are coming back your way Daphne.
avatar
Whoever thought that a toffee-nose would ever be out-classed by a prole? Magic! Pure magic!
avatar
Daphne you asked for it and you got it,it`s only the BEGINNING.
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
The national Pravda, not even a word about this libel suit.
avatar
come godo.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
Why so long? 12 years for a judgment ? Why was this case dragged over a 12 year span.. and the Blogger was left uncontrolled with her vile comments, "Blessed" by Gonzipn , in her cess-pit which she calls a BLOG? .................... Where the ay €950 in damages due to Mr. Cuschieri paid in cash cheque o Payment program or from the OPM Budget?
avatar
Godfrey Grech
Beautiful neck. Hawn min l-anqas ghandu wiehed.
avatar
@ Fellus ta Gahan . Tajb a din! haqqek prosit - Is-sahhara tal-Bidnijja u issa Olive Oyle! . Hahaha kompli dahhakna Dauphne please.
avatar
@ ta kafkaf You mean The Face That Launched A Thousand Libel Suits?
avatar
What's wrong with the picture? I think it brings her out very well. Lovely smooth skin and classic Greek features. No wonder she's called Daphne. Though i notice a tinge of colour on the upper part of the hair which I don't care for because her natural hair has such a nice colour.
avatar
For many years Dauphne's comments were an asset on the Sunday Times then she went over to the Sunday independent. But for many years now, from an asset she has become a liability with her extreme views and doing more harm than good to the Sunday Independent. I am an avid reader and follow most comments from every side of the spectrum but unfortunately she has ended looking like Manwel Cuschiere himself in his most controversial days. Time to go.
avatar
Anyone quoting this lady today?
avatar
Desiree' Attard
@Bonz +liberal Why buy newspapers at all when you could see and read everything on-line.
avatar
Esteban Hernandez
ghalli jista jkun din rebhet xi libel xi darba????????? wigbuni pls
avatar
Ouch ... This is what I call a bad weekend for Mrs Caruana Galizia. In a nutshell, she was not only found guilty (in another lawsuit which she lost), but she has been ordered to fork money out of her own pockets. That must be painful pupa, considering that only a few months ago you already lost another libel. And if I am not mistaken the woman has atleast 4 other pending libels cases. This must be really a tough moment for her. I am wondering will she be trotting up to her Independent bosses to help her out financially? Through the grapevine I heard that only a few years ago .... oh this is is the bliss of living in a small little, but so little world.
avatar
In a sense I pity DCG. At this rate she will be working hard to maintain her slander enabled pen and pay a string of libel damages payments. Perhaps Il-kbir ghadu gej .In her recent slander case involving a magistrate she stands a good chance of serving time in the pokey pokey if found guilty. Rather than concentrate on her obvious talents in editing cookery, fashion and social magazines she delights in spinning out of control and hurling amongst other things insults at all those within the political and institutional sphere whose behaviour or opinion do not coincide with her biased provincial and local view of what is proper and correct.
avatar
Seeing that pic, I understand why her nickname at school was "Olive Oyle".
avatar
@ bonz I agree 100% with your comment but I must add that I even stopped buying The Times and limiting myself just to read its news online and not reading the comments left by its readers. I cannot stand the same names writing cheap propaganda and showing their hatred to who does not agree with them.By the way I also cannot stand the bloggers always mentioning 1987 ,violence etc etc. I really cannot figure out who are and were the real "violent" people !!
avatar
The lady has now become one extremely big liability to the PN. The sooner the party distance itself from this hate machine, the better.
avatar
So much so for this PN whore! Good donation to Labour.
avatar
Dephny should let us know how it feels losing one libel case after another to labour people, it must be awful know that a pulita of her class is in the wrong whilst she has to pay a hamallu in fines. What goes round will come round.
avatar
I am not a fan of the lady ,and I never read what she writes. Honestly I pity her. It is because of her I stopped buying The Malta independent on Sunday, you cannot have a writer who slunders people left right and centre and found guilty many times for insulting people. Buying the newspaper is waste of money.