Backbencher insists on abstention, calls on EU to 'monitor' Gonzi's handling of situation

Nationalist MP Franco Debono has confirmed he will abstain from voting with government next Friday, in a reaction to a warning by Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi at the AGM of the PN youth movement MZPN that he expected all MPs to vote against Labour's call for Austin Gatt's resignation.

Addressing the MZPN annual general meeting on Wednesday evening, Gonzi revealed he had asked the Opposition to agree to a joint parliamentary committee o be set up with the scope of overseeing public transport, and also to postpone Friday's no-confidence motion against transport minister Austin Gatt.

Gonzi told the AGM he was insisting that he wanted Labour's motion to be amended into a “positive” one, and not just call for a minister’s resignation.

He announced the PN will be summoning its executive once more on Thursday evening, to discuss the amendments, but warned that should no agreement be reached, he was expecting “all government MP’s to vote against the Opposition’s motion.”

In a reaction to MaltaToday on Wednesday evening, Nationalist backbencher Franco Debono - who has threatened to abstain on the Labour motion - said he had decided to stand his ground and abstain from the vote.

He also said he would neither pen nor propose an amendment to counter the Opposition’s call for Gatt’s resignation, as had been mentioned by Gonzi at the PN's executive committee meeting last Monday.

“It is inconceivable to accept a situation where the Prime Minister decides to turn a clear issue of individual responsibility, into a matter of collective responsibility,” Debono said.

In his comments, Debono said the European Commission should “monitor” the way the Prime Minister “is handling such situations, where reforms fail at a heavy cost for the taxpayer.”

He also said the Prime Minister had not understood that this was a "clear issue of individual responsibility that has not been shouldered by anybody, as is normal democratic practice in other European Union member states.”

Last Tuesday, the Prime Minister revealed that he had refused Austin Gatt’s offer for resignation on October 3 during a Cabinet meeting.

Gonzi also told MaltaToday that public transport reform was part of the PN's electoral programme, and that the routes introduced in July were approved by Cabinet and not only by Gatt. "Minister Gatt has assumed political responsibility, and so does Cabinet, and I have informed the party executive last week that Gatt had offered his resignation during a Cabinet session, before MP Franco Debono had declared his position, and that I had refused the offer."

Gonzi has proposed that an amendment is made to the Labour motion that will also be characterised by an apology for the way the public transport reform was handled.

Debono’s position tonight changes the situation on the government benches, leaving Gonzi without a parliamentary majority that will require the Speaker’s casting vote to save Austin Gatt.

avatar
If nothing changes in Dr Debono's line of though from now till voting time, then I presume Austin will today surely experience a turbulent and sleepless night. I am very skeptic about the outcome of all this, but till now things do not look good for the PM and the PN. Obviously, the powers that be within the PN ranks are, at this very instant, working on overdrive to rattle Franco and make him change his stance. I would not be surprised one bit that a massive anticlimax to all this hype will be the end result. And as long as all this was not some idea of PN theatrics and massa in scena, Dr Debono is to be commanded for his 'political bravery'. The fact that Dr Debono's attitude has caused so much commotion showed us all that parliament is sometimes there to do more than simply serve as a rubber stamp by accepting mediocrity.
avatar
From here I am calling on Dr Gonzi and do us ex-Nationalists a favour and leave politics as he has doomed the party. He is not capable of running the party, let alone manage his parliamentarians. In my 51 years of existence, I have never met such a disaster within the party. When your own people show their discontent, it would be the time to pack it up. Hand over to John Dalli if you love your party. You should have not been there in the first place. It was only because you were pushed by EFA that you found yourself there. GONZI MUST GO FOR THE BETTER NOT JUST OF THE PARTY BUT ALSO OF THE COUNTRY
avatar
Franco you`ve got the guts to do it,don`t worry about Austin Gatt he could always find a job with ARRIVA as busdriver.......he`s got friends there.
avatar
Don't blame gonzi to go into panic mode, with 1998 still fresh in our minds when Mintoff first said he will abstain and then changed his mind at the last moment bring down Dr Alfred Sant's government, gonzi is affraid history will repeat itself and Franco might make a Mintoff.
avatar
In all fairness Austin Gatt shouldn't even vote as the motion is against him. . It is like asking a criminal to judge himself. . In all truth the vote is lost.
avatar
So gonzi's PIS are starting to tremble. . Now he asks the opposition to bail him out, be honest with yourself Lawrence,resign andcall fresh elections.
avatar
Well Done Franco. Finally an MP with BALLS!
avatar
I do hope that this poliitcal freedom retains it momentum also in the near future. not that I agree with Mr Debono,but this proves our state of mental poliitical freedom we live in.
avatar
bullying will not work forever!! The time where party members are gagged is hopefully over!!! Standing up for what you believe is not easy, but certainly admirable: well done to all those MPs who have some backbone, the others are just lackies and don't deserve to be in Parliament! Since Minister Gatt is not running for the next election (he would not be elected anyway, another Louis Galea) he should be held accountable NOW, an apology is not enough to set things right...
avatar
If the routes were approved by the whole cabinet, then all the ministers need to resign including the PM en masse and an election called forthwith. Then the next PM and Transport Minister can pull the carpet from underneath Arriva and come to a proper arrangement without any dangerous bendy buses around.
avatar
@N Spiteri There is no doubt that much must be going on behind the scenes to make him change his mind. Their love for power is too great to let it go. So much so that the PN is again convening this afternoon (their 3rd meeting since the crisis and that's besides yesterday's AGM of their youth section). Dr Gonzi has added pressure to bear on Dr Debono by calling on the PN MPs for their collective vote against the PL's motion. Now, whether Dr Debono plays in their hands remains to be seen. He seems to be very determined and is known for his strong character. One wonders what JPO and Mugliette would do! Mugliette, before being relegated to a backbencher, had been working on the transport system reform. As they say there is never a dull moment in the local political scene.
avatar
Hon Franco Debono, Beware !!!! You are confronting the holier-than-thou Girolamo Savonarola and Bruno Giordano rolled into one!!! Should you vote against, you will be burned at the stake by the Curia Party !!!!! Remember, had Dante Alighieri still been around, he would surely have relegated your opponent to Inferno. He would also have written Paradiso, and placed Macchiavelli in it !!!
avatar
At last....a true hero of the people!!
avatar
Well done Franco..Keep it up
avatar
denise vella
Dear Franco - Although I really admire you for you determination in putting the public interest before your party, and I totally agree with you, I wish you luck to keep strong till the last second because I am sure that they will do their utmost to make you change your mind. Note that although in their eyes you will not look loyal to the regime, rest assured that the people out their will thank you for your gesture/decision. Good Luck
avatar
The chickens are coming home to roost. We have a bizarre political system where both the legislative and the executive power is concentrated on a few hands (cabinet). This is not tenable. A two-party parliament where the majority party votes through whatever its' own cabinet says is not a parliament - it is a rubber stamp. For parliament to have role and maintain the seeration of powers we need a political reform: either a US/France style of executive President, or a European style multi-party parliament.
avatar
@John Azzopardi even though your comment was very informative regarding recent political events in Canada it is totally out of the point ! The issue thats making all the news is that we have an MP who is standing his ground at all costs to ensure whoever is accountable for the mess that is Arriva takes full responseability ! Considering the massive cost of the transition , a highly paid technical team and the 3 year time schedule afforded to the transport Authority the results are truly unbelievable and Mr.Gatt's Ministry has to pay the price for such poor handling of our nation's services. In Europe and surely in Canada , ministers who give this performance either resign or pay for it with their jobs and we do not deserve less. So Franco Debono stay strong, the courage you are displaying might rub off on some of your colleagues and maybe on some of the oppostion members too. The people will stand behind you.
avatar
Bye bye GonziPn. Hope Joseph will not go to his rescue!!!!!
avatar
@John Azzopardi -I have just read about a politician in canada introducing a bill that will disallow a member of parlament to cross over the other ailse. It makes sense, because a MP is elected by a certain group of people that favor certain ideas. It makes no sense at all cause we live in a democracy, or supposingly so. Have you ever followed the British Parliament?
avatar
It is obvious that the position has now become untenable for Dr Gonzi. There is one honourable way out for him. Call an early election. This country cannot go on like this with hiccups on the horizon every so often. Besides, Dr Debono there is also Mr Mugliette, JPO and Dr JP Faqrrugia who are revolting backbenchers. So it is not just one. The more this situation protracts the more damage is being to Malta. It's not easy letting power slip from your hands but it is the only honourable way out. The people expect Dr Gonzi to rise to the occasion. Now the onus is his and his alone.
avatar
@ John Azzopardi Debono is not switching party he is doing what he thinks his party should do.
avatar
I saw Debono's intervention on Reporter and the guy has some valid points which he is succeeding into highlighting through this public transport saga. I'm not a nationalist, but it is about time that ppl who have the national interest at heart voice their concern and be counted. Just recently we saw the likes of JPO also take a stand with members of the opposition which resulted in the introduction of divorce. This too was a stand that took guts and courage. It takes guts and courage to step up and take a stand against what your PM is suggesting, toeing the line no matter what. One hopes that in the near future politicians in Malta understand that their role is an important one, not for their own benefits, but for that of the country. I augur for a truly new way of doing politics.
avatar
Joseph Catania
Qed torqod issa Austin?
avatar
Now let us see if the Laughing Minister will have Debono's guts and resign, even if the motion is defeated with the Speaker's vote. And with him we hope the responsible idiots who created the routes resign as well eh.
avatar
I would accept Gonzi's proposition with the condition and commitment to hold general elections within six months!
avatar
I have just read about a politician in canada introducing a bill that will disallow a member of parlament to cross over the other ailse. It makes sense, because a MP is elected by a certain group of people that favor certain ideas. Franco, grow up. Read more below...... Floor-Crossing Ban Proposed By NDP Bill Memberss of Parliament shouldn't be allowed to switch parties while in office according to a private member's bill from a New Democrat MP that is being debated in Parliament Wednesday. Quebec MP Mathieu Ravignat introduced his private member's bill in September and it is up for debate for the first time. It seeks to prevent MPs from changing political affiliations during their term in office, something that has caused plenty of controversy on Parliament Hill. One of the most high-profile floor-crossings in recent years occurred in May 2005 when Belinda Stronach ditched the Conservatives for the Liberals and received a cabinet post in Paul Martin's government. The defection put an end to her personal relationship with Defence Minister Peter MacKay and helped Martin's minority government survive a crucial budget vote. Another shocker came a year later on Feb. 6, 2006, when David Emerson, elected as a Liberal a few weeks earlier, showed up at Rideau Hall for the cabinet swearing-in ceremony for Prime Minister Stephen Harper's new government. He was sworn in as Harper's trade minister and his floor crossing prompted outrage from voters in his British Columbia riding. “Members shouldn’t play petty politics and think only of their career, by changing political parties whenever they like,” said Ravignat in a statement. “MPs were elected personally, and under their party banner. We must ensure that members are accountable to their constituents.” According to the proposed legislation, a member who leaves his or her party would be deemed to have vacated the seat and he or she would either have to sit as an independent or run in a byelection.
avatar
Spot on Matrix, Gonzi wants Labour help when it suits him, I hope he sinks in his own muck.
avatar
Zack Depasquale
One of the last songs by Bob Marley was titled what goes around comes around, A Song I dedicate to the Gonz. What does the Gonz expect after all the insults, and a big payrise, that Labour should now save his skin from one of his backbenchers, doesn't he have any shame anymore? Did the one that changes his name according to the occasion (Fenech Adami), help Dr Sant's Government retain power or did he give all the help to Mintoff so that a legitimate government be brought down.
avatar
Of course the LP has done the same in the past. Politicians have the attitude of "they are dealing with a herd of goats"! Why? Because the majority of the Maltese voting public behaves like a herd of goats. Politicians, on both sides, are part of the society they come from. They know what works. Let's hope that incremental changes are happening and both major parties learn some lessons. Only then there can be some improvements in the Maltese political scene. Of course, by and large this is pie in the sky! It'll take eons for the situation to change as it'll need to change in society first and the media - most of which reflects the actual problem we tend to blame politicians for. Most - even most in the media are a herd of goats! One of the first things a Constitutional Convention should look at is the composition of Maltese Media and who owns it. No one should be allowed to present as an independent daily if the owners are a political party. now that'll be a change! And for the rest there should be a strong legally based commission that reports ONLY TO PARLIAMENT that oversees all other media(TV/Newspapers/on line) content.
avatar
Real democracy is coming to Malta,GONZIPN thinks he`s dealing with a herd of goats when all that comes out from his mouth is lies. Mr.Debono you are doing the right thing and you`ve got the guts to do it. Pity not all PN MPs are like you.
avatar
FRIDAY'S NEWS TODAY: Franco Debono abstained from the vote. The Speaker cast his vote and the LP motion was defeated.
avatar
One reads such a story with a dose of cynicism. One is not used to seeing Politicians in Malta stick to their guns for so long. In that respect: good on you Franco Debono. Malta needs more of such doers so those in power (Govt & Opposition) do not take the others(back benchers) for granted.And in turn it'll mean they do not take the voters for idiots (even though MOST voters in Malta are idiots - as they just follow their Party edicts and not think for themselves) In the long run this will only be good for Democracy and the way it is practised in Malta.
avatar
Dr Debono show that you are a real man that when you say something you keep your word .I wish that we have more politicians like you
avatar
Isabelle Borg
Postpone my foot. Mela qed nilghabu l-bocci jew?
avatar
Stefan Mifsud
I said it before and I will say it again. Dr. Debono, keep your balls on. It is people like you whom we need on both sides of the house to give us what we have been wanting through EU membership for which I have voted. A true democracy in our country. Something which we have not even put a dent on.
avatar
Should I laugh or should I cry after reading Gonzi's comments ....Pathetic !