Updated | Prime Minister denies Franco Debono claims to ‘buy’ his vote on Mifsud Bonnici motion

With promises of a car, a chauffeur and the Law Commission under his wing, government tried – and failed – to buy Franco Debono’s vote a few days before Carm Mifsud Bonnici was ousted.

Franco Debono said he was offered the trappings of a junior ministerial post if he did not vote against Carm Mifsud Bonnici.
Franco Debono said he was offered the trappings of a junior ministerial post if he did not vote against Carm Mifsud Bonnici.

Adds comments by OPM

The Office of the Prime Minister has denied that the government had attempted to stop MP Franco Debono from voting in favour of the Opposition's motion, by offering him a number of concessions amongst them the perks of a junior minister, according to the MP.

"The Prime Minister categorically denies these claims," a spokesman for the Prime Minister told MaltaToday.

Faced with the denial, an angered Debono told MaltaToday that the Prime Minister was 'lying' and claimed he was in possession of a document that proves the concessions he was offerred not to vote in favour of the motion that prompted the resignation of minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici. "The Prime Minister is lying. He is liar. I have a document that proves what I said," Debono said, adding that he was challenging the Prime Minister to face him "in front of everyone".

When asked whether he could provide MaltaToday with a copy of the alleged document, Debono however was not forthcoming. "I will give it to whomever I decide to give it."

Nationalist MP Franco Debono has claimed he was promised a chauffeur-driven car, a staff of four lawyers and taking control of the Law Commission by falling under the parliamentary committee for the re-codification of laws which he chairs, in return for his vote against the Opposition motion censuring the former justice minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici.

In a declaration that confirmed an earlier report published by the Labour press, Debono - who has broken ranks with the PN ever since he was banned from contesting the next elections on the party ticket - told MaltaToday he was actually offered a junior ministerial post.

"They offered me the post of parliamentary secretary by another name. But what they couldn't understand was that my actions were nothing personal against Mifsud Bonnici," Debono told MaltaToday.

"I repeatedly told the Prime Minister that he could give Mifsud Bonnici any ministerial post he wanted: but my problem was with him being responsible of justice and home affairs."

Whilst he refused to divulge the name - or names - of the mediator involved in the negotiations, Debono insisted that his issue had always been with guaranteeing accountability and for responsibility to be shouldered by the minister. MaltaToday had already reported on the meetings with senior PN figures before the crucial no-confidence motion that saw Debono vote with the Opposition.

Debono, a criminal lawyer by profession, said that he had experienced the shortcomings of the justice ministry and that this had led him to draft a motion calling for a reform in the justice and home affairs sectors.

In 2011 the MP embarked on a campaign seeking the split of the justice and home affairs ministry, with vocal outbursts in court complaining of the state of the criminal justice system earning him press coverage. He then claimed the Prime Minister gave him an assurance he would split Carm Mifsud Bonnici's ministry.

But a Cabinet reshuffle on 6 January left Debono out of ministerial promotion, prompting the maverick MP's rebellion: he refused to support Mifsud Bonnici in a May no-confidence vote presented by the Opposition, and voted with Labour leading to the minister's resignation.

At the time, Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi had said that he was not surprised by Franco Debono's vote in favour of the Opposition motion.

The question now remains as to what will happen when parliament reconvenes following the summer recess in two months' time. Debono has already warned the party leadership they are in for some trouble when Parliament reconvenes in October with, amongst other matters, a crucial and difficult Budget 2013 on its agenda.

"How can you condemn me and then expect me to back you in parliament?" a bellicose Debono had told MaltaToday, referring to his ousting from the party ticket for the 2013 elections for having voted for the resignation Mifsud Bonnici.

avatar
Il-Prim Ministru għandu akkuza serja ta' korruzzjoni għawnhekk jekk jirrizulta li hu veru li ipprova jixtri il-vot parlamentari tad-Deputat Dr.Franco Debono b'din il-wegħda. Jekk din ma tammontax ukoll għall korruzzjoni , mela korruzzjoni xi tkun ?
avatar
Franco Debono...nisthajjlek wahda minn dawk il-karozzi illi jbabzula is-silencer biex taghmel hafna, hafna U hafna hsejjes biex tahsibha xi sports car illi tghaddi rih umbaghad taraha ghaddejja b'xi 60km fis-siegha. Aghmel dak illi ghandek taghmel bi ftit kliem u mhux trid kulhadd itik attenzjoni.In altre parole: GROW UP!! Mhux qed tinduna illi issa qed taghmel iktar hsara lilek b'dan il-mod.Ahseb x'se jghidu l-istorici fi zmien mitt sena ohra fuqek? Il-kobor ta'bniedem mhux f'dak li jghid biss jitkejjel imma f'dak illi jaghmel. U int s'issa ftit li xejn ghamilt. Ghaddi daqqa ta'sieq lil GonziPN u ipprova ghal-leadership...u gib il-PN denju ta'partit politiku affidabbli...dan ikun il-kontribut tieghek lejn id-demokrazzija ta'pajjizek...inkella se tintilef.
avatar
@ falzonalfred6 " As this unfortunate saga drags on, Joe Citizen keeps loosing his trust in the same leaders that were elected to lead him. What a shame." >>> Why have you termed the truth as "a shame?" Isn't it true that most politicians are liars and spinners? We have ample proof how they twist facts and avoid promises made, don't we? We need to learn to elect honest citizens to these positions of power and wealth.
avatar
Rita Pizzuto
Din tassel kbira li deputat parliamentary jghajjar b'konvinzjoni mhux biss lill- mexxej tal-part it li jhaddan, imma lill-Prim Ministru, il- bniedem li jrid jmexxu pajjizna, GIDDIEB! Li kieku jghidha din ganni l-poplu jtellghuh il-qorti mixli 'malafama. Ghaliex lil Fanco le? Dan bniedem ta' gewwa li ghala avukat ma nahsibx li jfajjar bl-addocc insinwazzjonijiet hekk serji. Jien nistenna wkoll li ghandu l-provi. Jekk Gonzi ma jirribattix fil-qorti mhux se jigi emnut bill jichad biss. Ghall-Maltin Gonzi jitlef kill krettu ghax din akkuza serja. X'inhu, GIDDIEB Jew le? Hemm bzonn li din jibqghu naghfsu fuqha. Jekk Gonzi jipprova jhalliha ghaddejja, il-poplu le, ghax ma jhossux li hu komdu li kellu jimexxa minn GIDDIEB!
avatar
Maureen Attard
Meta ccanfar u tikkundanna dak li qalet jew kitbet fuq il-blogg taghha DCG u tiddisasocja ruhek u lil partit ghaziz taghna dwar dak kollu li qalet bi hdura u mibgheda kontra kull min ma hux ta' l-istess kulur politiku taghna, bl-ahhar hnizrijiet dwar l-ex Prim Ministru Dom Mintoff nemmnuk Dr Gonzi. Min m'ghandux dnub jitfa l-ewwel gebla u jekk il-partit taghna huwa veru demokratiku u KRISTJAN m'ghandux ikollu x'jaqsam ma nies bhal din il-mara. Partit kissirtuh. Mur gib lil Nerik Mizzi u George Borg Olivier jaraw lil-partit f'din is-sitwazzjoni prekarja.
avatar
Ara min irid elezzjoni bikrija! Is-socjalisti taz-Zero! Ara z-zmien 12.12.81 - 09.05.87 ma dejjaqhomx! l-aghar zmien ta' l-istorja tal-Maltin. Zmien moqziez ta'swat u diskriminazzjoni. l-iktar zmien mudlam xellugi tat-tqalligh u laqizmu tal-gvern lil dittaturi komunisti.Pett taz-zarbun jisthi iktar minn wicc is-socjalisti maltin. Viva l-Maltin! Il-Maltin u l-Liberta` l-ewwel u qabel kollox. Viva Malta Libera! Viva l- Lemin!
avatar
Let’s cut the crap :franco “In other words Mintoff stole you the limelight and nobody cares a f**k what you say or do anymore You were offered something and you wanted MORE. And you now lost EVERYTHING” You can only blame yourself for that Franco . People voted for GONZIPN not for Franco.
avatar
To me and a lot of others like me, Gonzi is the liar of the Century. As an ex Air Malta employee, after a letter of job assurance and security from Gonzi in 2008, I am now unemployed and at my age, virtually unemployable. Yes, we believe you Dr. Franco Debono- GONZI IS THE LIAR NOT YOU - ask the ex drydocks workers, Go, bus drivers - Gonzi will do anything to cling to his chair.
avatar
Ok so we have Franco calling for reform of the justice ministry yet here he is claiming he had documentation showing what he was offered in return for his vote. If he is so much into the reform then why has he not published this document and prove he is telling the truth, So much for reform. I do actually believe he was offered what he has stated plus much more. Thats how gonzipn keep peoples mouths shut. But Franco if you want the people to believe you and take you seriously (and not pull through on what you state like you have done before) then show us what you claim to have. Prove what gonzipn is really all about. HAVE YOU GOT THE BOTTLE TO DO IT,
avatar
FRANCO YOU LOST THE BATTLE AND NOW YOU WILL LOOSE THE WAR. FOR WHAT YOU HAVE DONE AND SAID YOU ARE NOT CREDIBLE ANY MORE.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
At this stage I opt to believe Dr. Franco Debono and not Dr Lawrence "DCG" Gonzi! Go "INDEPENDENT" Franco, what's keeping you?
avatar
Cut this crap. Go for an election and bow before the people's judgement. Is this democracy Mr Prime Minister ? Just keep in mind that although you claim that you have been elected democratically, it doesn't give you the right to rule in an authoritarian manner and remember also that your party didn't just get 1500 votes than it's rival, there are more Maltese citizens not voting for you than those choosing your reign. Democracy my A........
avatar
Who is saying the truth???? How about an affidavit Dr. Debono
avatar
E.AZZOPARDI : HAVE YOU EVER HEARD DR. GONZI ASK DAPHNE CARUANA GALIZIA TO APOLOGIZE TO DR. MUSCAT FOR ATTACKING HIM IN SUCH A VILE WAY. AND NOT ONLY DR. MUSCAT , BUT ALSO HIS WIFE MICHELLE AND HIS CHILDREN. BESIDES ALL THOSE WHO CRITICIZE GONZIPN ??? HER LATEST ATTACK WAS ON DOM MINTOFF AS SOON AS SHE HEARD HE HAD DIED. SHE WROTE ON HER BLOG, " HALLELUJAH, HALLELUJAH, I'M GOING OUT TO CELEBRATE " !!! WHAT DO YOU SAY ABOUT THIS ? DID YOU CRITICIZE GONZIPN FOR NOT ASKING DAPHNE TO APOLOGIZE ???
avatar
E.AZZOPARDI : HAVE YOU EVER HEARD DR. GONZI ASK DAPHNE CARUANA GALIZIA TO APOLOGIZE TO DR. MUSCAT FOR ATTACKING HIM IN SUCH A VILE WAY. AND NOT ONLY DR. MUSCAT , BUT ALSO HIS WIFE MICHELLE AND HIS CHILDREN. BESIDES ALL THOSE WHO CRITICIZE GONZIPN ??? HER LATEST ATTACK WAS ON DOM MINTOFF AS SOON AS SHE HEARD HE HAD DIED. SHE WROTE ON HER BLOG, " HALLELUJAH, HALLELUJAH, I'M GOING OUT TO CELEBRATE " !!! WHAT DO YOU SAY ABOUT THIS ? DID YOU CRITICIZE GONZIPN FOR NOT ASKING DAPHNE TO APOLOGIZE ???
avatar
GONZI ISSA SE JGHAMILLU LIBELL LIL FRANCO DEBONO, GHAX GHAJJRU GIDDIEB ??????? IBQGHU CERTI LI GONZI MHUX SE JKOMPLI JIFTAH HALQU FUQ DAN ILKAZ. LI L-PN JIXTRU L-VOTI U L-MEMBERI PARLAMENTARI, ILHA SSIR. TIFTAKRU META PPRUVA JIXTRU LIL MP LABURISTA , CAMILLERI, IL-BEDEQ MINN GHAWDEX, U TNEJN NAZZJONALISTI - SAID U CAMILLERI , KIENU SPICCAW IL-HABS ???!!!
avatar
When one of the backbenchers calls his own leader and worse still the Hon PM "a liar" then something is very wrong with our politicians. As this unfortunate saga drags on, Joe Citizen keeps loosing his trust in the same leaders that were elected to lead him. What a shame.
avatar
Tghid jaghmel programm ta xarabank peppi fuq din??????????
avatar
Igor P. Shuvalov
"How can you condemn me and then expect me to back you in parliament?" stated Debono. Everything is possible when we have a Prime Minister who to keep his seat is ready to accept in his fold somebody who is calling him a liar.
avatar
Igor P. Shuvalov
What are we talking about here: A written denial by the Prime Minister or what just a spokesman for the Office of the Prime Minister has stated? Can we have the exact words used as in many instances statements are worded in such a way that they deny something which is quite different from what is being alleged.
avatar
U tghejd mhux ser nemmen lil GonziPN.. l-istorja turina li mhux l-ewwel darba li il PN ippruvaw jixtru il vot ta xi membru fil parlament...U lil min tafu issaqsix ghalih....Jekk hemm il provi il President tar Republika ghandu jindahal ghax din kwistjoni serja.Ma jistax pajjiz jitmexxa b`dan il mod.
avatar
Zack Depasquale
Is there someone in Malta who still thinks that Parliament will meet on the 1st of October,the cohabitaion and IVF laws are all messa in scena, these laws will be discussed in another legislature certainly not this one. The oligarchy days are numbered. As for Franco Debono, if he wants to stay credible he should immediately publish any documents he has about this story, I am sure it will be a bigger story than Joe Grime telling someone playing priest where to go.
avatar
La l-Prim qed jinnega dan kollu, bil-Malti qed jghidlek Dr Franco Debono li int bniedem giddieb. Kieku kien flokok ma noqghodx ghaliha din.
avatar
Anette B Cassar
Ikolli nghid. Jien lest nemmen il verszjoni ta' FD aktar minn dik ta' L'DCG'G. :)
avatar
ma nafs kieku veru x'inhu straordinarju jew hazin? fiz-zmien alfred sant kien hawn xnieha li minfloku biex ma jirrezenjax il-gvern jinhatar george abela. veru? nixtieq li xi hadd jistaqsi lil president biex jichad din l-istorja jew jikkonferma. jigi mistoqsi jekk qatt semgha b'din. rigward franco debono jekk jahseb li se jkompli jaghmel hsara kif qed jipjana u jghid sejjer zball ghax il-gvern iressaq il-budget tajjeb u jekk ma jghaddix isejjah elezzjoni. rigward dr. karm mhux se nemmnu li ma riedx jehodlu postu. mistoqsija ghalih - qatt tkellimt ma' herrera fuq dan?
avatar
Gonzi should take Debono to court; otherwise we will believe Dr Debono!
avatar
ma nafs kieku veru x'inhu straordinarju jew hazin? fiz-zmien alfred sant kien hawn xnieha li minfloku biex ma jirrezenjax il-gvern jinhatar george abela. veru? nixtieq li xi hadd jistaqsi lil president biex jichad din l-istorja jew jikkonferma. jigi mistoqsi jekk qatt semgha b'din. rigward franco debono jekk jahseb li se jkompli jaghmel hsara kif qed jipjana u jghid sejjer zball ghax il-gvern iressaq il-budget tajjeb u jekk ma jghaddix isejjah elezzjoni. rigward dr. karm mhux se nemmnu li ma riedx jehodlu postu. mistoqsija ghalih - qatt tkellimt ma' herrera fuq dan?
avatar
ma nafs kieku veru x'inhu straordinarju jew hazin? fiz-zmien alfred sant kien hawn xnieha li minfloku biex ma jirrezenjax il-gvern jinhatar george abela. veru? nixtieq li xi hadd jistaqsi lil president biex jichad din l-istorja jew jikkonferma. jigi mistoqsi jekk qatt semgha b'din. rigward franco debono jekk jahseb li se jkompli jaghmel hsara kif qed jipjana u jghid sejjer zball ghax il-gvern iressaq il-budget tajjeb u jekk ma jghaddix isejjah elezzjoni. rigward dr. karm mhux se nemmnu li ma riedx jehodlu postu. mistoqsija ghalih - qatt tkellimt ma' herrera fuq dan?
avatar
ma nafs kieku veru x'inhu straordinarju jew hazin? fiz-zmien alfred sant kien hawn xnieha li minfloku biex ma jirrezenjax il-gvern jinhatar george abela. veru? nixtieq li xi hadd jistaqsi lil president biex jichad din l-istorja jew jikkonferma. jigi mistoqsi jekk qatt semgha b'din. rigward franco debono jekk jahseb li se jkompli jaghmel hsara kif qed jipjana u jghid sejjer zball ghax il-gvern iressaq il-budget tajjeb u jekk ma jghaddix isejjah elezzjoni. rigward dr. karm mhux se nemmnu li ma riedx jehodlu postu. mistoqsija ghalih - qatt tkellimt ma' herrera fuq dan?
avatar
I believe that before jumping to conclusion and then feel like jack ass there are some points to take into consideration. 1. Both Franco's and gonzi credibility is at par normally at Zero although Franco did have some credibility on some of his points only his reluctance to act which makes him unbelievable. On the other hand gonzi's credibility shouldn't even be considered. 2. Franco says that he has a document that would contradict what gonzi denied and confirm what he said. Sorry seeing is believing. 3. Don't you guys love this soap opera especially Franco's part, he's called gonzi a dictator, that he is being manipulated, he would not support the government unless gonzi resigns, calls him a LIAR (nothing new but ooouch) cries his heart out to be allowed back into GONZIPN etc etc Now who in his right mind would won't gonzipn to govern for another 5 years, unless they are part of the clique and oligarchy, or a bazuzlu or an opportunist who takes fat government contract and the rest with an IQ below 50.
avatar
Gonzupn jirranga il- problemi fil partit bi flus il-poplu, x` arukaza f` hiex wasalna, dik demokrazija!! X` ser jghidilna ta martin fuqha din?
avatar
Jekk hemm il provi ta dak li qeghed jinsinwa Dr. Franco Debono, hemm kas serju ta ksur ta gurament.Meta jiehdu il gurament meta isiru deputati ikun ta fedelta u lealta lejn il parlament u lejn poplu, u fuq kollox lejn ir Repiblika ta Malta minghajr biza jew indhil....Biex Alla jghejnhom u mhux il partit nazzjonalista. Din haga serja ghax fil pajjizi tal gungla jghamlu hekk. Ma nafx jekk l-Eccellenza tieghu il President tar Repubblika ghandux jindahal u juri ta l-anqas il karta is safra lil P.N.
avatar
Din gravi, li l-gvern prova jixtri deputat,fuq din biss ukoll ghanda tissejah elezzjoni
avatar
Milli jidher l-attentati għax-xiri tal-voti kien diġa beda , aħseb u ara x'hin titħabar id-data ta' l-elezzjoni x'inhu gej . Nispera li il-poplu Malti tagħallem mill-izbalji ta' l-imgħoddi u ma jirrepetihomx . Nispera wkoll , li ma jkunx hemm xi baħnan li għall xi pjaċir ta' qabel l-elezzjoni jasal biex jinsa kif gie stmat min dan il-gvern korrott u arroganti .
avatar
The proof of the pudding is in the cookies
avatar
If this is not "CORRUPTION", THEN WHAT IS IT? We want Justice for those involved. Parliuamentary Immunity should be abolished for the chosen few?
avatar
It's now printed on the wall. If Dr. Franco Debono is apt he should as by obligation to inform the speaker of the house about this grave substance with evidence and proof, so that Parliament has to resume without delay. This declaration should now be taken seriously by Dr.Gonzi if it is based on reality and should do his duty either to deny this allegation with firm evidence or admit it. If he does admit that there were talks with a mediator involved in the negotiations as proposed to Dr. Franco Debono an offer of a post of Parliamentary secretary by another name, in conjunction to vote not to censure the former justice minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici this would mean sheer misdemeanor, which is even computed as a severe legal or moral crime to the highest institute that is Parliament and even the commissioner of Police must take note and investigate.
avatar
Hemm ahna - ergajna, dejjem l-istess storja ---- il-bravu gonzipn, imwerwer li jitlef it-tronn li tant ihobb u li jitlef il-pozi u l-onorarja li tant ghandu ghal qalbu, IPPROVA JIXTRI MINN TAHT lil franco debono biex johodlu l-vot. BHALISSA GHADDEJJA L-ISTESS HAGA mal-pajjiz kollu - gonzipn ghaddej b'fernezija liema bhalha biex jixtri u jisraq il-vot tal-maltin b'kull forma ta' wieghdiet ... ipprova jixtri deputat tieghu stess, tahsbu li se jsib xi problema biex jipprova jixtri lil poplu malti? .... aktar ma jghaddi z-zmien, aktar gonzipn u l-klikka tieghu jidhru bhala grupp iddisprat ghall-poter li lest ikisser il-kaxxa ta' malta kif ghamlu l-klikka ta' qablu basta jibqa' jsaltan, jerda', jiffanga u jimla bwietu ....