Updated | Denial from OPM over EC court action on Marsa emissions

Brussels mulling court action over emissions from continued operation of Marsa power station - PM says he is not informed.

The European Commission could be taking court action against Malta over the Marsa power station emissions.
The European Commission could be taking court action against Malta over the Marsa power station emissions.

The Office of the Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi has denied telling MaltaToday that the European Commission will be taking Malta to the European Court of Justice over the level of emissions from the Marsa power station, when asked about the imminent action earlier in the day.

The OPM said the prime minister was referring to a reasoned opinion that was issued six months ago by the EC in June 2012 - the second step in an infringement procedure - but that the Maltese government was not informed that Brussels would be taking Malta to the ECJ.

MaltaToday specifically asked the prime minister whether he confirmed that the European Commission would open legal proceedings.

While the prime minister neither denied, nor confirmed court action, Gonzi also referred to the fact that the interconnector project would be in operation later than expected in 2014.

"We told the Commission... look, it's taking longer than we wished for, we wanted to do it earlier, but there were circumstances out of our control. But yes, I confirm that the EC said it would take steps against us.

"I hope these steps will not start, and that the EC will wait for some more time until the end of the year or the start of 2014, because the cable will be then operational."

MaltaToday understands that Lawrence Gonzi's answers were easily interpreted as a confirmation of the pending court action, and not specifically that he was referring to the reasoned opinion of June 2012.

This newspaper is reliably informed that Brussels has doubts as to whether the interconnector will even be operational by the end of 2013, a fact that has prompted taking further steps against Malta for not having decommissioned the Marsa power station.

The Marsa power plant was brought back into operation in 2012 due to a delay in bringing the Delimara plant online, in violation of the Large Combustion Plants Directive, the scope of which is to protect human health by limiting harmful emissions.

The government initially failed to reply to a letter of formal notice sent on 28 February 2012 within the stipulated two-month period. The formal notice is the first stage in a process that may lead to the Commission pursuing litigation.

Earlier today, MaltaToday revealed that the European Commission was preparing to take Malta to the European Court of Justice over the emissions from the Marsa power station, after having issued a warning back in February 2012.

A government source privy to EU policy affairs said Brussels was mulling court action six months after having sent a reasoned opinion to Malta calling on the government to comply on industrial emissions.

The case relates to the government's delay in closing down the Marsa power plant, which is still being operated because it still provides a portion of Malta's energy demands.

The Commission is expected to say that Malta has "failed to protect citizens from noxious air pollution from a major power plant."

Until late yesterday, however, the only comment from a spokesperson for the Environment Commissioner Janez Potocnik was: "No decision has been taken yet on the possible follow-up to the reasoned opinion."

Back in June 2012, the Commission said it was concerned that Malta had not yet closed the power station, issuing a reasoned opinion to the government - the second step in an infringement notice issued by Brussels.

Under the Large Combustion Plants Directive, Marsa's four combustion plants were not supposed to exceed a 20,000-hour limit between 2008 and 2015, but all four plants went over that ceiling in 2011. The plant will have to be decommissioned by not later than 2015 - in the meantime, Enemalta pays a daily fine to MEPA for operating the power station, due to its emissions.

The power station produces 45% of Malta's electricity, but MaltaToday is informed that the Commission has been told that the Malta-Sicily interconnector will not be ready in time for the Marsa power station to be closed down by 2013.

Six months ago in June, the EC claimed that Malta was "failing to protect its citizens from pollution emitted by the Marsa power station."

avatar
Luke Camilleri
TORT TA' JOSEPH MUSCAT, LI DR. lAWRENCE GONZI MA JAF B'XEJN??? Mela dan ghal fejn ghandhu il-Ministri, is-segretarji Parlamentari, l'ASSistenti Segretarji Parlamentari, il-Ministeri taghhom , il-konsulenti taghhom IMBGHAD johrog Gonzi jghid li ma jaf xejn???? NEMMNUH?????
avatar
Six months ago in June, the EC claimed that Malta was "failing to protect its citizens from pollution emitted by the Marsa power station." The question beckons; If the emissions are not harmful, as Minister Cassar & experts told us, why doesn't the PN government contest this ruling? I think that the PM, ministers Fenech & Cassar should apologise an resign. This is another blatant lie exposed by the EU and these people think that they are beyond reproach! Disgraceful.
avatar
" The hope is that the European Commission waits just a bit longer so that by the start of 2014, the interconnector will be operational," But my dear Gonzi our lungs do not wait a bit or rather for several years!
avatar
And THE TIMES OF MALTA doesn't report this !!... thanks Dr Gonzi
avatar
The Commission is expected to say that Malta has "failed to protect citizens from noxious air pollution from a major power plant." We were told by our prime minister that both plants which generate electricity are not harmful to our health, now european union is suing us for failing to protect our citizens from noxious pollutant what is going on in our country we must be marching backwards like a crab.
avatar
mhux bilfors ser nehlu il multi jekk gonzipn/600euros bil mohbi dejjem kien interessat fil heavy fuel oil.u jien ta cuc li jien il ghala ma marx mil l ewwel ghal pipe line tal gas li it taljani offruh b'xejn.xi haga tinten hemm zgur.kien ikollna il gas min sqallija u il power station tal yellow pages kienet iddur bil gas barra il cable min sqallija.imma gonzipn.......ried imur bil fors ghal heavy fuel oil..iftah mohhok ja poplu.
avatar
Dan huwa il-Futur fis-Sod Dr Gonzi. U hallina u mur stahba jew emigra. Kollox ghamilt biex tfalli dan il-pajjiz. Daqt naqaw fiz-zona tal-JUNK. Min huwa responsabli ghandu jirrispondi ghall ghemilu jew il-haddiem iz-zghir imur il-habs u ihalllas il-multi???? Nispera li mhux tort ta Joseph Muscat?? Gustizzja, Gustizzja, Gustizzja
avatar
Anette B Cassar
Tajjeb Gonz. Ibqa faqqarna ta.