Update 2 | Man wrongfully prosecuted on hold-up files for compensation

Darryl Luke Borg gives testimony to police inquiry into wrongful prosecution for Birkirkara store hold-up

Darryl Luke Borg leaving the Ministry for Home Affairs after giving his testimony before the Police Board. (Photo: Chris Mangion/MediaToday)
Darryl Luke Borg leaving the Ministry for Home Affairs after giving his testimony before the Police Board. (Photo: Chris Mangion/MediaToday)

Additional reporting by Chris Mangion

A man who was wrongly accused of committing a store hold-up has filed a constitutional application for compensation, claiming breach of human rights.

A magistrate had ordered that Darryl Luke Borg, 27, who was accused of carrying out a hold-up on a Birkirkara store, be kept under arrest at the Mount Carmel forensic unit where he was undergoing a treatment order.

Two days later his lawyers were informed on 9 August that another man, Roderick Grech, had admitted to the hold-up. Borg was freed that same day, but his lawyers also realised that their client had not been detained at Mount Carmel but at the Corradino Correctional Facility.

In their constitutional application, lawyers David Camilleri and Joseph Gatt complain that Borg should not have been arraigned in court in the first place, or denied bail, and that the police should have freed him a day earlier on 8 August when police learned that Grech had admitted to committing the hold-up.

This morning, Borg gave his testimony to the Police Board at the home affairs ministry, where an inquiry into his wrongful arrest is being carried out.

A government source said that it was the ministry's chief of staff, Silvio Scerri, who contacted Borg, asking that he has his say before the board.

Borg was accompanied by his mother to the police board inquiry, which is being led by emeritus judge Franco Depasquale.

Police Inspectors Joseph Mercieca and Carlos Cordina were also asked to appear before the board today. Merceica and Cordina had led the prosecution when Borg was arraigned.

avatar
The same happened to me, 28 hours locked up just because some sent an anonymous letter. The Most Democratic PM Minister we had (Dr L Gonzi) didn't answer my letter when I wrote to him. The real culprit who is still running around, while my family and myself had to endure this saga. I also remember the late Joseph Pace (the man from Gozo) who continued fighting until he died, and I still remember certain Maltese BIG HEADS giving him the cold should showing him how much they believe in JUSTICE and DEMOCRACY.
avatar
It is incredible. The man wrongfully accused was placed in detention for two days (and could have been much more) by the Magistrate when he was innocent until proven guilty and the man who admitted the hold up was sentenced by a different Magistrate to 1 year detention but suspended for 3 years and therefore did not do one single minute in jail. What sort of justice is being meted out by the Judiciary, and could this be one of the reasons why they opposed the changes in the Judicial proceedings by the Board headed by Judge Emeritus Dr Giovanni Bonello. We cannot keep on having this disparaging variations in sentences which are so glaringly inconsistent and unjust.
avatar
Our Law Courts badly need a reform which is undergoing and the Police Force as well. They were left on their own whims by the previous administration to a disastrous consequences. Unfortunately our compensation laws in Malta are inadequate and need updating but if Mr. Borg wins the case it has a great moral victory. The Police inspectors messed up pretty badly and need to be disciplined. It is a nightmare for the Justice and Home Affairs ministries at the moment. Nevertheless, I wish Mr. Borg success in his endevours.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
WHO WAS the magistrate had ordered that Darryl Luke Borg, 27, to be kept under arrest ?????