Slideshow | Dom Mintoff at 94 - 10 of the best and 10 of the worst

On Dom Mintoff’s 94th birthday anniversary, MaltaToday salutes the fiery former Labour prime minister with a reminder of Il-Perit’s 10 moments of glory and his 10 moments of shame.

 

10 moments of glory

1947 As Dr Boffa’s public works minister, and an up-and-coming architect, he was engaged in reconstruction and slum demolition in Cottonera.

1959 Mintoff envisions Malta’s future as a neutral member in the European Union when proposing his vision for Malta as a ‘Switzerland in the Mediterranean’ in an article entitled A New Plan for Malta, penned for the New Statesman in 1959.

1962-1971 51,000 “soldiers of steel” still vote for MLP in the general elections despite the Church’s imposition of mortal sin. In 1971, Mintoff wins by a slim one-seat majority in parliament after the Church lifts its imposition of mortal sin on Labourites in 1969.

1972 After nine months of negotiations with Britain, Mintoff finally signs an agreement extending for another seven years Britain’s right to use Malta as a naval base. Mintoff did not get the $72 million in annual rent he originally demanded, but he did get a handsome $36.4 million – about three times what Malta received before Mintoff started setting deadlines for British withdrawal.

1973 Mintoff’s first government decriminalises homosexuality.

1974 Malta ditches British monarchy to become a republic – a move also supported by most Nationalist MPs. The non-partisan former British governor Sir Anthony Mamo is appointed President.

1975 Mintoff introduces civil marriage – a measure which for the first time makes a distinction between Church and State.

1979 The introduction of the two-thirds pension scheme, the payment of one-twelfth of a wage or salary per week as a Social Security contribution for entitlement to two-thirds of his pensionable income. In 1980, maternity leave is also introduced.

1979 Closure of the British military base as Malta shifts its fortress economy to new pastures.

1986 Mintoff brokers an agreement between the two parties which enshrines majority rule in the Constitution together with neutrality and non-alignment, thus paving the way for a change in government in 1987.

10 moments of shame

1949 Mintoff splits Labour into two after ousting the moderate Paul Boffa, depriving it of a majority until 1955.

1956 Mintoff pushes for integration with Great Britain despite clear signs that Britain was not even interested. In a referendum, 75% vote ‘Yes’ for integration but the result is questionable due to a boycott by 40% of the electorate in response to concerns raised by opposition parties and by the Catholic Church.

1973 Mintoff nationalises the National Bank of Malta without offering compensation to shareholders.

1970s Mintoff closes the Faculty of Arts, imposing a strictly utilitarian policy on university courses.

1975 Mintoff holds up the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe for 52 days as he stubbornly insists on a special insert on Mediterranean peace and security in the CSCE declaration.

1978 Mintoff tames the General Workers Union by incorporating it within the Labour Party through a statutory fusion, clashing with former union leader Joe Attard Kingswell in the process.

1979 The offices and printing rooms of The Times of Malta are ransacked and set on fire during a spontaneous political rally by MLP supporters following allegations of a failed attempt on Prime Minister’s life in his offices at the Auberge de Castille. Mintoff fails to condemn the violence.

1981 Labour remains in government notwithstanding the fact that 51% of the electorate voted in favour of the PN. The victory is sanctioned due to the supremacy of seats, which is constitutionally legal.

1984 Mintoff handpicks Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici as his successor, depriving his own party of a strong leader as he keeps pulling the strings.

1998 Mintoff denies Alfred Sant a majority in parliament on the Cottonera yacht marina motion, paving the way for Nationalist re-election and the re-activation of Malta’s EU membership application, which he would later campaign against.

avatar
@ Falke: You're sick man and in urgent need for help!
avatar
Mario Said
Falke's first argument clearly shows his hatred for the drydock workers by stating that the deficit is due to the money thrown in to keep the drydocks afloat. As far as I know the Nationalist Party inherited a surplus in '87 not a massive hole in our finances. Falke did not mention the many boards and directors set up by the NP to accomadate their blue eyed boys. Falke did not mention that according to Caritas we never had so many school levers which are illiterate. Falke did not mention that a large percentage of Maltese are living below the poverty line. And Mr Falke all this under a democracry not a dictatorship.
avatar
I believe you are one of these nationalist bastards, that is what Mintoff did is all wrong, just to make you remember that Malta didn't have its National Airline, its National Cargo Shipping, The Free Port, it was also damaged by war. The visions Mintoff had for Malta where excellent, see what we in today in this bloody EU with its shit currency the Euro, all Maltese build companies sold to foreigners eg Malta Dry Docks, Free Port. Sea Malta due the incompetence of your arrogant minister A Gatt wasn't even sold it was liquidated. When EFA took government he found a stable government with billions in the Malta Box, after 25 years of PN what do we have is a big hole in the box, loans and deficit. Malta L'ewwel qabel Kollox
avatar
Tony Sultana
Tourists and foreigners who visit Malta or come to live here are often surprised by the good standard of living of the Maltese people and when they compare us with other European nations they conclude that Malta is a ‘wealthy’ country. ‘Wealthy’ owing to our Social Services, way of life and education. The formative years for all this to be possible were during Dom Mintoff’s time.
avatar
I cannot understand why it is shameful to insist for a a special insert on Mediterranean peace and security in the CSCE declaration.
avatar
John Mifsud
@Joe South 1. The deficit you mention. Much of it is due to the money thrown away at the Drydocks to keep it 'afloat'; 2. A bloated public sector; 3. A quixotic foreign policy, where our natural friends became adversaries, and our new friends were the likes of Kim il Sung, Gaddafi, Arafat, Mugabe etc, not to mention the disgraceful antics in Helsinki and Madrid. This continued to haunt us and helped keep us out of the EU for 14 years after we applied; 4. Keeping us out of the EEC/EC/EU for a quarter century. According to the 1970 agreement, Malta would have joined by 1980 at the latest; 5. Sowing division and hatred at all levels in the country; 6. Using patronage and corruption as instruments of policy; 7. The needless - an ultimately counterproductive - 'battles' against the Church; 8. Instilling a culture of envy, false entitlement and dependancy; 9. Wrecking first our secondary schools and later our entire tertiary educational system. Need I go on? I would be here till tomorrow, at least. The fact that the administrations which followed did not always have the gumption for a radical change of course does not shift the responsability from the man.
avatar
1. Britain wanted integration, and then changed its mind. Read Pirotta's book. 2. Mintoff did condemn the ransacking of Strickland House. Read his letter to Mabel Strickland. Please do not distort history.
avatar
Richard Demicoli
It was Dom Mintoff-God bless his soul- who changed the island's economy based on military spending to a "normal" economy based on industry, and tourism. Again, it was Dom Mintoff who gave birth to the Maltese Welfare State and civil rights now enshrined in his 1973 Republic Constituion.No change is brought about without resistance, and yet few if any blood was shed. Compare this with other birth pangs of other nations, chief amongst them the USA where people were discriminated against because of colour up to the 60's whilst super "European" Switzerland only gave the vote to women a decade ago!
avatar
Alfred Galea
Flake, how was 71 a fluke? And what problems are a "direct result of his "misrule"" Are you talking about the problems of children's allowance, free health, free education and decent pensions?? Or the problems of annual deficits and four billion euros national debt?? Can you clarify please? Thank You.
avatar
John Mifsud
Unlike Raphael Vassallo, I fail to see any positives in Mintoff's legacy. Many of the problems which continue to haunt us are the direct result of his misrule. Malta's great tragedy was his fluke election in 1971. I have neither forgotten, nor forgiven anything.
avatar
Alfred Galea
Whenever you get a children's allowance cheque, free health care, free schooling for your kids, twice yearly bonus, a decent pension and use one of the best social safety nets around ALWAYS REMEMBER, THAT DICTATOR made them possible. MS.......just in case you don't know, NORMALLY dictators get 100% of the votes, so Dom must have been one lousy dictator.
avatar
Albert Zammit
Well, we have lived through Mintoff's years and all I can say that it is the most shameful characteristic in Maltese history - that in spite of what he did to the country, people continued to vote for him in such large numbers - always 49% more or less. It shows that so many of the Maltese are unable to live without a dictator telling them what to do.
avatar
Ian George Walker
It was not Mintoff who split the party in 47 - it was those MPs who refused to abide by the legal and open decision of the General Conference to elect Mintoff as leader. And Malta's stance at the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe in 75, far from being a "moment of shame" was one of our proudest moments - when we showed that we could stand up for our rights, despite our small size. Whoever drew up that list has a very biased and skewed perspective.