Updated | Mizzi replies to accusations of pardoning energy thieves

Nationalist Party says Enemalta’s decision not to take criminal steps against consumers involved in energy theft ‘shameful’.

The Nationalist Party has lambasted the Labour government for pardoning consumers embroiled in rampant energy theft from Enemalta, insisting that pardoning acts of corruption was "shameful".

In a statement, Enemalta said individuals who come forward with any irregularities in their or in their electricity consumption readings will avoid criminal proceedings.

"Enemalta confirmed what the Prime Minister said yesterday: amnesty will be given to those who bribed public officers," the PN said.

It added that the energy theft scandal was not only about the "€30 million stolen from Enemalta" but it was also about "bribing public officers to acquire tampered electricity meters".

The PN acknowledged that Enemalta regulations stipulate that the corporation could choose not to take criminal steps against those who tamper with meters.

"However, acts of corruption and bribing public officials are different acts, separate from theft of electricity. Government cannot pardon this criminal act as if nothing ever happened," it said.

The PN added that Prime Minister Joseph Muscat was going to "pardon 1,000 people who committed corruption and bribed Enemalta officials", accusing him of "interfering with the course of justice".

"Police still have to proceed criminally against the 1,000 individuals who bribed the officials," it said.

The PN added it was "shameful" that Muscat was pardoning corruption while "bragging about his fight against corruption".

"We expect all acts of corruption to be investigated by the police and the police should not allow its work to face political interference," the PN said.

In reaction, energy minister Konrad Mizzi accused the opposition of holding double standards, adding that the PN was opposing its efforts to have the stolen energy paid by the perpetrators.

Stressing that former finance minister Tonio Fenech was aware of the theft, which in 2011 and 2012 "exploded to €30 million" a year, especially since this was flagged by the Auditor General, Mizzi said that the previous administration had introduced a law allowing Enemalta to enter a administrative agreement with the perpetrators.

Pointing out that the current administration was only following the law, Mizzi said that consumers who were involved in the theft would be asked to pay for the energy stole, including interests and a 10% penalty.

The statement however said that unlike previous PN administrations, the Labour government was doing its utmost to uncover the scam and was "tough" on the masterminds of this racket.

REACTION

Energy minister Konrad Mizzi has reiterated accusations against former finance minister Tonio Fenech, that under his stewardship over €30 million in electricity generated was consumed without being paid for.

Both Mizzi and Fenech have sued each other for defamation over accusations they have been trading with each other, since the findings of Enemalta's 'theft control unit' which found over 1,000 smart meters had been tampered with. Three Enemalta employees were charged with organizing the racket.

"Fenech is saying he knew nothing of this phenomenon despite a report from the Auditor General identifying this clear problem. The former government introduced a law allowing Enemalta to reach administrative agreements with whoever steals electricity," Mizzi said.

The Theft Control Unit was launched in May 2013 to understand why electricity being consumed was not being paid for by both residential and commercial users.

Enemalta is calling on consumers to come forward to regularise their position and pay what they owe, with interest and penalties.

The Opposition, on its part, says the waiving of criminal procedures against consumers who were party to an act of corruption, meant the government was pardoning guilty parties.

"The Opposition is not interested in catching whoever is behind this racket. Instead they want the government to embark on a witch hunt instead of collecting the money that Enemalta is owed.

"The government is acting according to the law, being strong with those who created this racket and the public officials involved in it. They will also be sued for damages. The Opposition should explain why it never took action in the years it was in government, when it was aware of this theft."

avatar
@Guzepp - Were you living in Timbuktu during the twenty five years preceding 8th Mach 2013 ??? @camillu - Do you have such a short memory??? What about George Farrugia who paid bribes to Enemalta officials to procure oil for the corporation???
avatar
Taking an apolitical stand I consider there are two main issues here. Certain civil liability and potential criminal liability. (1) Civil liability is being addressed via the facility (as per Enemalta 2006 regulations in situ) that offenders would themselves approach Enemalta and consent to settle the difference between their registered consumption and their estimated realistic consumption computed by the Corporation; pay an additional 10% penalty on top; pay interest on the outstanding dues from date of credit afforded; pay for the installation of and the cost of a new meter which they would have damaged and finally tell on who actually involved them in this scam. (2) Criminal liability may be mitigated by taking advantage of the Whistle-blowers Act in full; thereby uncovering the whole rigged system, and finally the mastermind, whilst concurrently being afforded relief from prosecution under that same Act.
avatar
Maureen Attard
How many amnesties were given to those evading VAT during the Last 5 year of PN administration?
avatar
If all defaulters were prosecuted then I think over half would be dead by the time their case came to Court, such is the speed at which the Justice system works. Taking the practicable approach, recovers the money (plus a fine) and sorts out who will be left to prosecute if those people do not voluntarily come forward. Resolve the issue and leave the 'mud slinging' to those who think that squabbling like children over politics is the way to run a Country and its Economy.
avatar
Jiena niftakar zmien fejn il-partit Nazzjonalista kien repetutament ihambaq fil-mass meetings u l-mezzi tax-xandir li l-korruzzjoni f`Malta kienet bl-eruq u x-xniexel,mela din x`inhi? Kienu jghidu wkoll li konna f`xifer l-irdum. Eddie kien iwieghed li jekk il-poplu jaghtih il-fiducja kien jaghmel minn kollox biex jeqrida. Jiena wiehed li afdajtu. Thawwad mhux ftit meta f`gheluq is-sena tar-rebha f`mass meeting kolossali fuq il-fosos, qamet uforija kbira u capcip kbir hekk kif qalilna “ ir-rih tal-bidla diga qieghed jinhass u ghamilna pass il-quddiem”. M tantx domna li ma bdejniex nisimghu bil-mirakli tal-ilma li sar wisky u l-hgieg li saru mirja, li l-Armier imtela kontejners u wara saru kmamar, u stejjer ohra li jafhom kulhadd. Altru li nqatet il-korruzzjoni.
avatar
Dan Simon ukoll bhal proverbju bibliku ma jarax it-tavu f'ghajnu (ma ghamel xejn jew anqs biss qara ir-rapport ta awditur) u qed jitkaza bit-traba ta haddiehor!
avatar
Sham on you Konrad and on your leader.The corrupt, that is the people who bribed others to tamper with their electricity meter, are being forgiven instead of taken to court. Under PL it pays to be a criminal! Xifajk, the PN never pardoned anybody accused of corruption. It'sd only Muscat who's doing it.
avatar
Nahseb il-PM Muscat f'dal-kaz mexa kif ghamel Simon Busuttil, b'differenza li Muscat qed jahdem ghal gid nazzjonali, waqt li Busuttil hadem ghal butu. Tiftakru qabel l-elezzjoni Simon Busuttil thallas barra l-qorti ghal sehemu fis-Shell. B'hekk heles malajr u serrah rasu. Hallina Simone, u halli lil min jaf imexxi b'onesta' imexxi
avatar
Mark Fenech
Tal-PN imisshom jgħidu min bidila l-ligi dwar is-serq tal-elettriku. Din inbidlek ftit snin ilu mill-Ministru Austin Gatt, jidhirli fuq parir tal-AG, biex flok joqoghdu jtellghu nies il-qorti dwar serq tal-elettriku, jaqbdu u jaghmlu stima u penali. L-anqas tafu kemm inthom giddiebin.
avatar
Just some reminders to the PN - http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20060606/local/1-400-come-clean-on-electricity-theft.51708 http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20090904/local/income-tax-amnesty-scheme-announced.272175
avatar
Who is the twit who said "crime doesn't pay"?
avatar
....Labour government pardons acts of corruption – PN....... How many amnesties did the Nationalist Government give during the 25 years of their administration. Aren't AMNESTIES SAME AS PARDONS?
avatar
Shame mhux tighd li minn hu hati jersaq wahdu inkella tithol il pulizija imma SHAME fuq minn kien jaf li kienet qed issir din il hniezrija u ma ghamel XEJN . Jew issa tridu li tihdu il krettu ukoll . Isthu jekk tafu .
avatar
Shame Shame Shame on the Government if they forgive these people that broke the law. This is in defiance to what our laws stand for or is it? Break the law and the government forgives you all especially if you happen to be on the right side of the fence.. Since when is it that the government ignores the courts and bypasses our rule of law? If the government truly forgives these people for breaking the law then they must absolve everybody else, even those that cheated and took bribes in the Oil Scandal, no worry about the Mep Scandal because the Government has already forgiven them. They have also forgiven the person who managed to call the Gozo Ferry back to port when they were left behind. Are we really that much of a corrupt country?
avatar
Igor P. Shuvalov
Yes let's take action against 1000 people with the possibility of having 1000 suspended sentences and most of the people not paying back their dues and fines!! Yes let's add to the law courts backlog, at least some people would be able to fatten their pockets!!
avatar
THE SAME PEOPLE WHO WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR CLOSING THEIR EYES AND EARS ON THIS ENORMOUS SCANDAL, THINK THEY CAN NOW TELL THIS GOVERNMENT WHAT IT SHOULD DO IN THE PRESENT CIRCUMSTANCES !!!!!!!!!
avatar
Maybe Simon and the PN should stop shooting themselves in the foot. The PN were the ones to recommend granted a presidential pardon in the oil procurement scandal and let at least one big fish get away with it, or was it a different type of bribing officials? Or Simon and the PN should maybe file a judicial protest, like they did for the IIP program and come out officially that they will repeal any pardons given by Enemalta and the Government and that when in Government he will prosecute.So stop beating around the bush as the PN leadership is currently seen as intent of completely destroying what is left of the PN
avatar
Il-PN jaf x'jigifieri jahfer?? Jahfer meta dawn in-nies ma jroddu xejn lura. Il-fatt li dawn iridu jroddu sal-inqas 1c plus 10% penali jfisser tahfer? Mela nsew dawn li meta kien hemm l-iskandlu tal-VAT il-gvern tal-PN kien kompla jaghti l-kuntratti lil min kien involut primarjament f'dan l-iskandlu! Mela din xi tfisser??