Prime Minister's 'wait-and-see' on Roma expulsion, 'we wait for Brussels's verdict'

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi took a cautious stand on the expulsion of the Roma from France, which the European Commission is now investigating.

In comments to the press, Gonzi said the EC was “duty-bound” to investigate any infringements of EU law, and that the outcome of these investigations would determine whether any law was broken.

France has deported hundreds of Romanian and Bulgarian Roma back to their countries of origin over the years, but recently has increased the pace of expulsions.

But Gonzi stopped short of affirming a clear stand of disapproval on the Maltese government’s part of the expulsion of Roma people, who are also EU citizens.

“The point is this: the rule of law must apply to everybody… but we must recognise that directives exist, directives that gives rights to EU citizens, and that the European Commission is duty-bound to see that these directives are abided to, and if not, it has the right to take steps,” Gonzi said after a European Council meeting in Brussels today.

“France has accepted this and one hopes this matter is cleared in the next weeks, to see whether EU directives were infringed or not. We await the outcome of those investigations.”

French President Nicolas Sarkozy said he was "deeply" shocked by the sharp criticism of his country's deportation of ethnic Roma, also known as Gypsies, and said France would continue to dismantle Roma camps.

Sarkozy's defiant comments Thursday threatened to overshadow an EU summit called to discuss economic issues.

EU Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding and Sarkozy have spent days exchanging harsh words over the expulsions, which Reding had suggested had overtones of Nazi-era minority deportations.

Although she stepped back from her harsh criticism Thursday, Reding has held fast in her rebuke of the French government and earlier statements that Paris could face EU disciplinary actions.

French leaders have lashed out against the criticisms, calling them "unacceptable."  Sarkozy has described the break-up of Roma encampments and their deportation as part of a crackdown on crime.

Leaders have gathered at the Brussels summit to discuss ways to prevent new financial crises after the economic turmoil that has roiled various European countries.  But the dispute between France and the EU leadership over Paris' policy of deporting the ethnic Roma minority is overshadowing other issues.

Sarkozy and EU Commission Chief Jose Manuel Barroso were reported to have had a "fierce exchange" over the Roma during lunch.

avatar
Ina Cini
They are EU citizens but living in illegal setups and they cannot afford normal residency. So they are a social burden, hence eligile for expulsion. So would be for Estonians or Maltese if they resort to such methods. But they happen to be Romas, and so it is obvious that they are targetted. So what? Political correctness shall never hinder legality. It is not that difficult to grasp. Do you think that only the Maltese have the right to guard their empty spaces? No freedom or right is absolute or sacrosanct.
avatar
One of the important rules of the EU is the free movement of citizens between member states. The Roma are EU citizens. Not only that but the French government is basing their roundups purely on racial factors. It is specifically aimed at the gipsies and excludes migrants from other countries like Estonia or Malta.
avatar
rcasha a country belongs to the people born there not to settlers and roamers. That's what caused and will continue to cause wars, civil unrest and revolutions. Witness certain arrogance and the undercutting of local workers by foreigners and illegal immigrants, their incompatible and many times third-world countries traditions and disregard for local customs and traditions not to say laws in our tiny most overpopulated country where we don't have enough breathing space for ourselves. If things continue as they are, what are we going to do? Start stacking people on each other? We need breathing space not accepting everyone who comes here whether legally or illegally and allowing them to remain and settle here. The situation in Malta is like a boiler building up steam without any safety valve and when the pressure gets too high it will explode with dire consequences. That's what the authorities are inviting to happen in Malta. As the saying goes, those who have eyes to see let them see and those who have ears to hear let them hear before its too late. For then there will be no stopping the people as happened many times in other countries and even in Malta.
avatar
Hmmm.... forced relocation based on race. Now where have I heard that before?
avatar
Ina Cini
Sarkozy is right, legitimately. EU citizens should afford residence in another country in order to be able to move and reside freely in it. Not settling in ever expanding illegal camps on French fields. I wonder what the environmentalist have to say! What if such a problem infested Malta? We need more national leaders like him. And less like indecisive, EU submissive, Dr. Gonzi. Mr. Sarkozy, the majority of people are with you on this issue. And no one can take your rights as a statesman.
avatar
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100916/ap_on_re_eu/eu_eu_summit France defies EU criticism on Gypsy expulsions http://uk.news.yahoo.com/22/20100916/tts-uk-eu-france-roma-ca02f96.html Sarkozy, EU leader clash over Roma dispute http://uk.news.yahoo.com/18/20100916/twl-sarkozy-hits-back-as-roma-row-explod-a2f61c0.html Sarkozy hits back as Roma row explodes at summit http://it.notizie.yahoo.com/4/20100916/tts-oittp-eu-summit-rom-ca02f96.html Rom, scontro Barroso-Sarkozy. Berlusconi a Ue: consultazione http://euobserver.com/9/30826 Sarkozy unleashes 'violent' tirade against Barroso http://euobserver.com/9/30797 Populism on the rise in the Nordic region http://www.norden.org/en/analys-norden/tema/social-democrats-crisis-or-rebirth/the-strange-death-of-social-democratic-europe The strange death of social democratic Europe