Euro for Greece was a ‘mistake’

French President Nicolas Sarkozy has said allowing Greece into the eurozone in 2001 was a "mistake," the BBC reported.

He said Greece was "not ready" at the time. But, he added, it could be rescued thanks to Wednesday's EU deal on the euro debt crisis.

In response, Greece's foreign minister told the BBC that Athens was not the source of the crisis, and that no country should be made a scapegoat.

The agreement reached in Brussels has triggered a worldwide shares rally.

In a TV interview on Thursday, Sarkozy said admitting Greece to the eurozone had been "a mistake" because the country had "entered with false [economic] figures. It was not ready".

He added that he was confident the current Greek government would emerge from the crisis and that Wednesday's deal had averted a "catastrophe".

"If Greece had defaulted, there would have been a domino effect carrying everyone away," Sarkozy said.

Speaking to the BBC, Greek Foreign Minister Stavros Lambrinidis said: "Greece is in the middle of the storm, but it is not the source of the problems of European debt and deficits.

"We see this with Portugal, Ireland, Spain and Italy. So it doesn't help to scapegoat a particular country when you're dealing with a European problem."

The comments come after European leaders clinched a deal at marathon talks in Brussels. The main provisions are:

Banks holding Greek debt are to accept a 50% loss

A new mechanism is to boost the eurozone's main bailout fund (the European Financial Stability Facility) to about €1tn

Banks must also raise more capital to guard against losses resulting from any future government defaults

The agreement is aimed at preventing the crisis from spreading to larger eurozone economies, but the leaders said work still needed to be done.

On Friday, Klaus Regling, chief executive of the EFSF, held talks in Beijing, as the eurozone bloc continued its efforts to persuade China - and other emerging economies - to help rescue it from its crippling debt crisis.

Analysts say that a possible Chinese investment could be up to $100bn, a BBC correspondent in Beijing reports.

But China is seeking guarantees from Europe that its investments will be safe, he adds.

Hailing Wednesday's deal, European Commission President Manuel Barroso said: "Europe is closer to resolving its financial and economic crisis and to getting back on a path of growth. We are showing that we can unite in the most difficult of times."

He said the post of "super-commissioner" would be created to deal with the euro.

US markets joined Europe's share rally. The Dow Jones index ended the day up 2.86%.

London's 100 share index finished up 2.9%, France's Cac up 6% and Germany's Dax 5% higher.

The biggest gainers were banks, led by French institutions, which are the most exposed to Greek debt.

Fears about the state of the eurozone's finances and the threat of a break-up of the single European currency have been stalking markets for months.

The 50% debt write-off by banks means that Greece's debt burden could drop from 160% of GDP to 120% by 2020.

Eurozone leaders said the firepower of the EFSF would be boosted from the current €440bn to about €1tn - although details remain to be worked out.

The framework for the new fund is to be put in place in November. Germany, as the largest economy in eurozone, is expected to be the largest contributor.

Bank recapitalisation was agreed earlier.

The banks will now be required to raise about €106bn in new capital by June 2012, and governments may have to step in, despite the unpopularity of further bank bail-outs.

avatar
@ Stephen B -What we need is better and more responsible politicians. WHERE DO YOU PROPOSE TO GET THEM FROM PRAY?? JUPITER? ALL PEOPLE IN POLITICS ARE TRASH OTHERWISE THEY WOULD NOT EVER CONSIDER SUCH A HORRID OPTION. ALWAYS BEEN TRASH BUT NOW IT IS REEKING!! THE EU IS NOTHING MORE THAN HITLER'S DREAM GONE WRONG AGAIN. HOW CAN IT EVER GO RIGHT??
avatar
The European Union concept is good and so is the single currency concept. What is not good is that the people who run the European Union are elected because of popularity in their respective states not because they are good for the job at hand. At the moment the concept of a single currency across the European Union has turned sour because irresponsible people in high key political places where unable to control excess spending which accumulated to height debts which are hindering the live hoods of millions of Europeans. What we need is better and more responsible politicians.
avatar
The whole eu project was a big historical mistake. ** Human Torch we are waiting for a big bang not a boom. ** Moribund if they were not afraid of the answer they would hold referenda together with the MEP's elections, but they are CHICKENS and know the answer they will get. ** We must do our utmost to leave this artificial colonialist club where we are the colonized by the Brussels regime.
avatar
@Ken...so did Malta give the correct economic statistics according to you? Do you think we are better than Greece economically or we are just waiting for a boom!
avatar
Greece pretends it shouldn't be singled out, yet it is obvious that the entire country has a black market economy and almost everyone avoids paying their taxes. The Ministry charged with dealing with tax- dodgers is so understaffed that according to French television they had TWO controllers for the entire country. It is a joke, but no-one is laughing. I've been to Greece; I predicted disaster as soon as they entered the Euro zone as I knew that they would be incapable of doing anything correctly, would welsh on their promises, would try to scam everyone. I was right. Within two years after entry the other countries were already complaining that Greece was not following through on any of its responsibilities. None of this is a surprise. What the Euro Zone needs is a way to force recalcitrant nations OUT of the zone until they get their act together properly. There is no reason why the rest of Europe should sink because one or two countries are incapable of keeping their commitments.
avatar
Now they tell us.Were the other near defaulters(so far) a mistake as well, was the idea of a United Europe the biggest mistake of all ?. Why not ask the people of Europe if they like the idea of the European Union,or are you afraid of what the answer would be?.